Skip to content

2021 MMDBL All-Stars

AI-selected: the league has never voted on All-Stars, so these teams were picked from 2021's results by one fixed set of rules. How they were picked.

Season: 2026 · 2025 · 2024 · 2023 · 2022 · 2021 · 2020 #2 · 2020 #1

Bull Durham All-Stars

10 clubs · 25 players

Starting lineup

PosPlayerClubPAAVGOBPSLGHRRBISBValue
CTravis d'ArnaudToronto175.291.360.4626311+6.1
1BColin MoranSan Francisco131.222.359.4727171-0.4
2BDJ LeMahieuSt. Louis251.332.394.4968413+10.7
3BAlec BohmToronto259.336.421.4914260+13.0
SSTrea TurnerLed league: AVG, SBChicago Cubs252.348.401.630103114+23.8
LFMookie BettsLed league: HRChi White Sox229.315.406.61915386+13.8
CFJackie Bradley Jr.Pittsburgh209.317.407.5116291+10.1
RFAustin SlaterChi White Sox165.303.442.5004223+7.7
DHMiguel RojasChi White Sox142.328.437.5555233+12.1

Reserves

PosPlayerClubPAAVGOBPSLGHRRBISBValue
CMax StassiChicago Cubs143.266.364.4275150+3.5
2BMike BrosseauMilwaukee196.313.418.4765143+8.7
SSTim AndersonMilwaukee215.332.381.4726233+8.6
DHNelson CruzOakland245.311.420.54411410+8.1
CFGeorge SpringerLed league: RBIBoston234.260.368.49013440+7.0
3BKe'Bryan HayesDetroit115.340.417.5403151+6.8
RFAlex VerdugoToronto219.303.370.53510351+6.1

Pitchers

RolePlayerClubGGSW-LSVIPERAFIPSOValue
SPYu DarvishLed league: SODetroit15158-20103.02.713.03137+22.4
SPZack WheelerLed league: W, ERAChi White Sox12129-2086.22.283.0170+21.0
SPTrevor BauerChicago Cubs13138-4094.02.783.25135+18.9
SPDinelson LametBoston13136-2078.02.542.86103+18.4
SPBrandon WoodruffBoston12123-4080.12.693.0398+17.5
RPJames KarinchakToronto1903-0127.11.652.5657+8.3
RPDevin WilliamsToronto2103-5530.02.402.4266+8.0
RPMatt FosterLed league: SVChi White Sox1821-21226.21.693.2436+7.0
RPRaisel IglesiasLed league: SVPittsburgh1901-21222.12.422.6435+5.7

The Natural All-Stars

10 clubs · 25 players

Starting lineup

PosPlayerClubPAAVGOBPSLGHRRBISBValue
CWill SmithMinnesota228.258.382.47911340+10.9
1BFreddie FreemanNY Yankees239.325.460.63912420+19.0
2BRobinson CanoMinnesota +1242.345.393.5299350+11.9
3BMike MoustakasNY Yankees150.264.400.5217260+7.4
SSJose IglesiasNY Yankees247.356.413.5184241+15.3
LFJuan SotoLed league: AVG, RBIMinnesota266.393.504.79017539+37.0
CFCody BellingerTexas215.279.400.5208424+10.5
RFBryce HarperAtlanta242.270.434.4819338+9.3
DHPaul GoldschmidtTexas +1250.312.468.5318350+13.8

Reserves

PosPlayerClubPAAVGOBPSLGHRRBISBValue
CDaulton VarshoWashington150.190.367.4146210+3.8
SSFernando Tatis Jr.Led league: HRLA Angels239.252.326.58920473+11.4
CFIan HappLA Angels231.282.372.52011440+8.9
2BCesar HernandezTexas226.316.416.4462271+8.4
LFDavid PeraltaPhiladelphia199.362.407.5246253+7.9
1BEdwin RiosPhiladelphia168.264.351.66214330+7.3
SSAdalberto MondesiLed league: SBLA Dodgers236.259.333.41052814+0.9

Pitchers

RolePlayerClubGGSW-LSVIPERAFIPSOValue
SPCorbin BurnesLed league: ERABaltimore14124-4177.11.863.12110+20.0
SPClayton KershawPhiladelphia11115-2066.02.053.3877+15.5
SPLucas GiolitoLed league: WMinnesota14148-3087.03.003.70125+14.2
SPHyun-Jin RyuLA Angels12123-3081.12.883.7093+13.8
SPShane BieberLed league: SOTexas13133-5080.04.503.80134+6.0
RPGreg HollandAtlanta1902-1238.11.172.8151+12.1
RPTrevor RosenthalLed league: SVTexas2203-11031.21.991.7158+10.4
RPTony GonsolinPhiladelphia1574-4262.23.163.7965+9.4
RPLiam HendriksNY Mets1301-0719.10.001.5634+8.7

How the All-Stars were picked

The MMDBL has never voted on All-Stars, so these teams were selected by AI from each season's regular-season results, using one fixed set of rules for every season:

  • Two squads a season, one per league, 25 players each: nine starters (C, 1B, 2B, 3B, SS, three outfielders and a DH), seven reserves, five starting pitchers and four relievers.
  • Value is runs above an average player, from each season's regular-season results. For hitters: batting (wOBA against the season average), plus steals, plus the standard adjustment for how hard the position is. For pitchers: runs saved against the season's average pitcher, half on ERA and half on FIP (strikeouts, walks and home runs).
  • Starters are the most valuable player at each position (the position he played most; DH if he played the field in fewer than half his games), the three best outfielders, and the best remaining hitter at DH.
  • League leaders in batting average, home runs, RBI, stolen bases, wins, ERA, strikeouts and saves are automatic All-Stars.
  • The rest of the bench (with a second catcher), the rotation and the bullpen are the most valuable players left.
  • Every club gets at least one All-Star, as in MLB: a club left out gets its most valuable player in place of the lowest-valued reserve, starter or reliever.
  • Playing time: hitters need 2 plate appearances per team game, starting pitchers 0.8 innings and relievers 0.25. A player's whole season counts, every club included; one traded between leagues is an All-Star where he played most.

2021 averages: wOBA .339, ERA 4.82. Value is in runs: +10 means about ten runs better than an average player over the same playing time. Badges mark a league leader and a club's only All-Star. Numbers come from the Player Record Book.