Skip to content

T.W.I.B. › 2020

Week 6 - The Natural is Dominating Everything Again

Last season, The Natural League owned The Bull Durham League. That’s not hyperbole.

Natural teams went 93-67 versus Bull Durham teams, a .581 winning percentage. Only three Natural teams (the Angels, Phillies and Nationals) had losing records versus Bull Durham teams; and only three Bull Durham teams (the Cardinals, Dodgers and Diamondbacks) had winning records against The Natural. The Mets feasted on Natural teams, going 12-3. The Natural was so dominant that even the A’s, winners of 70% of their games, finished below .500 (7-8) against Natural opponents.

It’s a new season, and one-third of it is already in the books. Once again, Bull Durham teams are getting worked by their Natural opponents. This season, The Natural is 51-27 versus Bull Durham, a .654 winning percentage. Oakland is the only Bull Durham team posting a winning record against The Natural, and none of The Natural teams has a losing record against Bull Durham foes. The Mets are still liking Bull Durham opponents, as evidenced by a 7-2 clip, and half of the Phillies 14 league-leading wins have come against Bull Durham teams.

The Natural dominance is obvious when you peruse standings and statistical leaders. Only two Bull Durham teams (Boston and Oakland) have winning records, and those are the only 2 teams in their league with positive run differentials. Conversely, only two Natural teams (Baltimore and Washington) have losing records, and the Nationals are the only team in their league with a negative run differential. Pitching appears to be the difference maker. The top 5 pitching teams in the MMDBL are all, naturally, from the Natural.

The Lowdown on the Season’s First Third

Bull Durham’s Sparky Division Recap – Boston holds a 1-game lead over Oakland after taking 2 of 3 from the A’s this past week. The Red Sox, coincidentally, took 2 of 3 from the A’s to end Season #1’s first 1/3rd, and it was the last series the A’s lost until they bowed to the Twins in the World Series. The Red Sox are 11-7 and the A’s are 10-8, and both are better than their 9-9 starts to Season #1.

At this point in Season #1, The A’s and Red Sox were 2 games behind the then division-leading Dodgers. After fading with a 15-21 record in the final 2/3rds of the season, the Dodgers moved to Chicago’s southside and have continued to struggle. The White Sox are 6-12 to start Season #2, 5 games back. Pittsburgh is in 3rd place in the Sparky with a 7-11 record, 4 games back. The Pirates moved from Tampa, where last season they posted a 21-33 record and were 6-12 at the 1/3rd marker. Milwaukee is tied with the White Sox at 6-12 after vacating Chicago’s north side where they finished Season #1 at 25-29.

It was about this point last season when the A’s took off. After falling to 9-10, the A’s went 29-6 to finish the regular season. Could it happen again? Possibly. The A’s are one of the better balanced teams in the MMDBL with the 5thbest OPS and the 5th best WHIP. Comparatively, Boston is 2nd in OPS but 15th in WHIP. Boston’s next 2 series are at home versus the Pirates and the Cubs. Meanwhile, the A’s will go on the road for series against Milwaukee and Pittsburgh.

Bull Durham’s Casey Division Recap – At the 1/3rd mark, the Cardinals are where they were post-to-post last season – in 1st place. But it has been a struggle. St. Louis (9-9) took 2 of 3 from Detroit (8-10) this past week to edge a game ahead of the Tigers. The Cubs, Giants and Blue Jays are all 7-11, 2 games back, with the arrow trending up for the Cubs (formerly the Rockies.) Chicago is 6-4 in their last 10 games, whereas division foes all have losing records in the last 10.

Last season, St. Louis shot out of the gate, going 5-0, winning 9 of their first 10, and holding a 13-5 record at the 1/3rd mark, second best in the MMDBL. The 5-game winning streak to start the season remains an MMDBL record. The Cards cooled off, but finished 28-26, winning the division 1 game ahead of the Jays and 2 ahead of the Diamondbacks (now the Giants.) This season, the Cardinals stumbled out of the gate. But so has everyone else. The Cardinals have a minus-6 run differential, but the rest of their division foes have run differentials ranging from minus-21 (Cubs) to minus-35 (Blue Jays.) Toronto leads the division in scoring with 87 runs, but it also has allowed 15 more runs than any team in the MMDBL (122). Toronto has the 4th best OPS, but is dead last with a team WHIP of 1.65. St. Louis, on the other hand, has the 4th best WHIP (1.25) and 14th best OPS. The other divisional teams have bottom-half metrics in most key categories.

One contributor to the Casey Division’s struggles is how poorly it has fared against The Natural foes. Casey teams are 12-27, a .308 winning percentage against The Natural. This is important because St. Louis will play The Natural’s Angels this week, whereas the other Casey teams have divisional series (Detroit at Chicago, and Toronto at San Francisco). If St. Louis were to lose the division lead, it would mark the first time that the Cardinals are not in sole possession of 1st place or tied for 1st place in the Casey since the MMDBL was formed.

The Natural’s Whitey Division Recap – A year ago, the Mets were the hottest team in the MMDBL at the 1/3rdmark. The Mets went 9-1 in the first 10 games and held the league’s best record at the 1/3rd post, 15-3. New York went 18-18 the rest of the way to finish 33-21, winning the division by 1 game over Milwaukee (now Baltimore) and 2 games over Houston. The Angels finished 8 games back and the Phillies were in last place, 9 games out, and the only team in the division with a negative run differential.

In Season #2, the Mets are off to a decent start (10-8), but the big story in the Whitey Division is the emergence of the Phillies. Philadelphia is 14-4, best in the MMDBL at the 1/3rd mark, and on an 8-game winning streak, the longest in the league in Season #2. Last year, no one scored fewer runs than the Phillies (182). Already in Season #2, Philadelphia has 109 runs scored (4th best) and has a legitimate chance of scoring more runs by the 2/3rdmarker than it did in all of Season #1. The Phillies are 5th in OPS, and while they have allowed fewer runs than any other team in the MMDBL, they are 13th in WHIP.

The top division rival right now is the Angels, who are 2 games back at 12-6. The Angels are continuing to bludgeon opponents, leading the league in runs (124), homers (39) and OPS (.883). Pitching has been improving and they are currently 11th in WHIP. The Astros, like the Mets, are 10-8, 4 games back. The Mets have the better run differential (+15 vs +5) and both teams are close in key metrics. Houston is 8th in OPS, the Mets 10th. The Mets are 7th in WHIP, the Astros 10th.

Baltimore is 8-10, 5 games back, after being swept by the Phillies in a series in which they were outscored 10-5, including a pair of 1-run games. Despite their record, the Orioles have a +10 run differential, have allowed the 3rdfewest runs, and are 7th in WHIP. The lack of run production is astounding, considering the Orioles rank 7th in OPS. However, Baltimore is batting dead last with runners in scoring position (RISP) at .195 and dead last in RISP/2-out at .181.

Houston is the next division foe to have a shot at the Phillies, playing at Philadelphia this week, before the much-awaited Angels-Phillies matchup the next week. The Mets will host the Orioles this week and the Angels will play an intraleague series at St. Louis.

The Natural’s Tommy Division Recap – Minnesota led the Tommy Division at the 1/3rd marker in Season #1 with a 12-6 record, 1 game ahead of Texas. Little did anybody know at the time that the Twins were breaking out and would go on to win the division by 15 games over Texas. The Twins went 31-5 the rest of the way. By midseason, the outcome of the Tommy Division was no longer in doubt. What was in doubt was whether or not the Rangers would catch the Braves, which they eventually did. Meanwhile, the Yankees lost Aaron Judge for the season and pitching faltered badly. And the Nationals went on to the worst record (17-37) in the MMDBL, with the Yankees only 2 games better (19-35).

Season #2 has started notably different. Texas is pacing the division (12-6), and is 2 games ahead of the Twins and Yankees (both 10-8), and 3 games ahead of Atlanta (9-9). Washington is hanging on at 7-11, 5 games back. Texas has a +35 run differential, 31 runs better than the next closest divisional foe (Atlanta), so their 2-game lead belies the fact that the Rangers have been dominant at times. But don’t sleep on the Twins. Despite losing Mike Clevinger for the season, Minnesota has rebounded from a 1-5 stretch by going 4-2. And don’t sleep on the Yankees, either. They have 3 quality series wins versus the Red Sox, A’s and Mets, and lost the swing game to Texas last week by giving up 3 runs in the 9th. Had J.B. Wendelken saved Game 18, the Yankees and Rangers would be tied at 11-7.

From a metrics standpoint, Texas is 3rd in OPS, followed by Houston at 8th, Minnesota at 9th, New York at 11th, and Atlanta and Washington at 16th and 17th, respectively. From a WHIP perspective, the Twins are 3rd, Yankees are 8th, Rangers are 9th, Astros are 10th, and the Nationals are 12th. There are some big divisional tilts this week as Texas hosts Atlanta and Minnesota travels to DC. The Yankees will play an intraleague series against the Brewers. The following week we will be treated with the much anticipated Rangers-Twins matchup at Target Field in Minneapolis.

At the 1/3rd mile marker, there’s no saying how the MMDBL’s race to the playoffs ends. One thing is certain: There’s a lot of baseball yet to play and anything can happen.

The Rundown

Phillies sweep the Orioles

Cardinals take 2 of 3 from Tigers

Twins take 2 of 3 from White Sox

Rangers take 2 of 3 from Yankees

Brewers take 2 of 3 from Pirates

Red Sox take 2 of 3 from A’s

Cubs take 2 of 3 from Blue Jays

Angels take 2 of 3 from Mets

Astros take 2 of 3 from Giants

Braves take 2 of 3 from Nationals

The Week Ahead