Seattle Dealing With a Stacked Deck of 5 Aces
A year ago the Seattle Mariners ran an on-base centric offense with little power. It was a Moneyball approach – load up on guys who get on base, find a few gap hitters, see a lot of pitches, and wear opponents down.
In one sense, the approach worked for a team in transition. Under new leadership, the Mariners relocated from the Bay Area where they competed for league titles as the Athletics during the MMDBL’s first three seasons. But the cupboard had gotten barren due to a run of injuries and performance regression, and the club’s last season in Oakland deteriorated quickly as a mish-mosh of role players simply couldn’t produce.

What Seattle did last year is put the league on notice that they will be a tough out. Literally. While the club won only 34 games (.405 winning percentage) and had a minus-83 run differential (3rd worst), it managed to finish 5th in on-base percentage (.339) while walking 4th most and striking out 3rd least. However, the team lacked bash. Even a little cheap power would’ve helped. Seattle finished last in homers (70) and 2nd to last in extra-base hits. The plucky offensive approach resulted in the 13th most runs scored – not bad for an offense who’s star performers were an aging Charlie Blackmon and journeyman Ben Gamel. The Mariners did have Kyle Schwarber who, notably, accounted for 33% of the team’s home runs!
The offensive strategic direction of new leadership was becoming clear even before the season’s first pitch when it dealt young ace Walker Buehler to Texas in a package that returned Jeff McNeil (2B), Jose Urquidy (P) and a 1st round pick in the 2022 Rookie and Free Agent Draft that became Nestor Cortes. Nobody foresaw Buehler’s injury, but everyone knew what McNeil was all about. The pitch-selective, on-base maven is the prototype for “tough out” and his acquisition signaled that an offense culture shift was taking place in the Great Northwest. The culture shift continued with the acquisitions of Blackmon, Donovan Solano, Jon Berti and Yandy Diaz.
Defense Wins Championships
The axiom goes, “Defense wins championships” and in baseball, defense begins with pitching. So if you’re wondering where the 50 losses and minus-83 run differential for the 2022 Mariners came from, look no further than pitching. The Mariners were last in ERA (5.20), had the 3rd worst WHIP (1.45), yielded the 2nd highest batting average (.267) and gave up the most runs (457). No matter how many Jeff McNiels and Charlie Blackmons you have in your lineup frustrating opposing pitchers, it will be tough to win with pitching like that.
This brings us to the 2023 Seattle Mariners and their pitching transformation. The club established its offensive identify in 2022 – get on base and produce enough runs to be in every game if, and it’s a big “if”, there’s quality pitching to rely on. Well folks, there’s quality pitching to rely on in Seattle these days and that is the No. 1 reason the team now has the MMDBL’s 2nd best record (9-3) and 2nd best run differential (plus-23).
The pitching transformation actually began last season with the acqusitions of Cristian Javier and Nestor Cortes, who joined ace Julio Urias, a holdover from the old A’s. The two new acquisitions combined for 58 MLB starts last summer and an amazing 7.0 WAR. Both finished their MLB seasons with sub-1.00 WHIPs and batters managed to hit only .188 versus the lefty Cortes and an even more paltry .169 versus the righty Javier, who emerged as a post-season star for the MLB 2022 World Series Champion Houston Astros. Meanwhile, in his 2022 MLB season, Urias would not be outdone. The lefty added 3.2 WAR (that’s 10.2 WAR among Urias, Cortes and Javier in case you’re counting) and also limited hitters to a sub-.200 average and sub-1.00 WHIP.
Urias, Cortes and Javier gave Seattle a trio of aces entering the MMDBL offseason. So why not add two more aces?
Risk and Reward?
That’s exactly what Seattle did, completing deals for ageless Max Scherzer and Jake DeGrom who, by almost every metric, has been the MLB’s best starting pitcher over the most recent 5-year window. The trades are not without risk and reward, however. In both deals, Seattle gave up a combination of younger players and picks (Adley Rutschmann was one of those picks.) And both Scherzer and DeGrom are the Dynasty League version of ticking time bombs given their “F” durability ratings. Last year, Toronto navigated its way to the World Series with “F” Mike Trout lasting the whole season. However, it’s a lot more likely to fool the dice gods with a DH than a pitcher or fielder (see 2022 Twins and Byron Buxton). So far, so good. Degrom and Mad Max are a combined 4-1 over 5 starts with infinitesimal opponent batting averages and sub-1.00 WHIPs.
No one knows how 2023 will turn out for Seattle, but the longer the Mariners are able to run a 5-ace rotation, the greater the likelihood that they will find themselves in the newly expanded post-season, even if the offensive profile remains pop-less (Seattle is last with only 3 homers so far.) Through 12 games, the Mariners are tied for 1st in WHIP (0.95), 2nd in opponent batting average (.204) and 2nd in ERA (2.38). The transformation is driven by the 5 aces, who lead the league collectively in most categories, but the bullpen is not slouching. Seattle relievers are 2nd in WHIP (0.93), ERA (1.61) and 3rd in opponent batting average (.202).
If there were any questions about the Mariners’ identity, they’ve been answered. They will be a tough out offensively and complement that approach with strong run prevention dominated by the rotation. Scherzer and DeGrom may have durability concerns this season, but what if they erase those concerns heading into next season? Mariners’ brass, no doubt, is dreaming of a 5-ace rotation that doesn’t need to worry about a season-ending injury here or there. There’s risk now, but that could be the longer-term reward.
Quick Hitters
- In the MMDBL’s first 4 seasons, you could count on The Natural owning the Bull Durham league. So far in 2023, the tables have turned. Bull Durham is 70-53, a .570 winning percentage, versus The Natural. Only 3 teams in the Bull Durham are below .500 and only 3 teams in The Natural are above .500. Starting the season with 5 successive weeks of inter-league play has created some buzz while also creating some mystery. For example, teams are beginning to get a sense of where they need to improve, but no one really yet knows how well they stack up against their league rivals.
- The two-time MMDBL champion Minnesota Twins are 3-9, tied for the league’s lowest winning percentage at .250, and just ended a league-longest 6-game skid. That said, their plus-1 run differential is 10th best and they have lost 6 1-run games. Moreover, during their 6-game slide they faced aces Scherzer, DeGrom, Urias and Aaron Nola. Botton line: The Twins aren't dead; they're just getting started on their title defense.
- Detroit is 10-2 and sitting atop the Bull Durham with the league’s best record. Their plus-23 run differential is tied with Seattle for 2nd best. The Tigers own the league’s longest winning streak of the season – a 9-game run that ended last week in a shutout loss to Baltimore and Carlos Rodon. Similar to Seattle, pitching is leading the way. The Tigers have the league’s best WHIP (0.95), ERA (2.33) and opponent batting average (.191).
- The Phillies are once again shot out of a cannon and leading The Natural. The club is 8-4 and has the MMDBL’s best run differential at plus-27. Two seasons ago the Phillies 'Tampa Bay Ray'd' their pitching staff and almost won a World Series. The Phillies are at it again, averaging a league-low 4 2/3 innings per start while posting the 6th best ERA (3.48). But the hitting is off the charts. Philadelphia leads the league in OPS (.808) and is 3rd in batting average (.281), 3rd in OBP (.345), 3rd in homers (15) and 2nd in runs (65). Against lefties, the Phillies lead every significant offense hitting category with a gaudy slashline of .381/.425/.610/1.035. Perhaps most importantly, they lead the league is the all-important runners in scoring position (RISP) slash -- .318/.379/.604/.962.