Skip to content

T.W.I.B. › 2024

Snow-Covered Hopes: The Rookie & Free Agent Draft details are out

For each team in the Metro-Milwaukee Dynasty Baseball League (MMDBL), the next season begins as soon as they move on from the current season. This could be at the trade deadline -- well before it, in some instances -- or after they are officially eliminated from contention.

Fenway Park sits snow covered, hoping a winning franchise graces its green grass and Green Monster come spring.

For instance, the Toronto Blue Jays (formerly the Chicago White Sox) moved on from the 2024 season March 26 when they dealt Aaron Nola to the San Francisco Giants. The Cubs moved on May 15 when they traded closer Raisel Iglesias to the Dodgers for a draft pick; and Kansas City unofficially moved on June 18 when it dealt closer Josh Hader to Baltimore for a player and a pick.

Baltimore didn't move on from the 2024 season until the very end. Instead, it welcomed Hader and went on a colossal run to claim its first-ever World Series championship. For Baltimore, preparations for the 2025 season began October 9, the day after it beat Seattle to win it all.

For everyone, the "official" start of the offseason was October 9 -- the day the trade window re-opened. It will officially end February 12, 2025, on Opening Night of the 2025 season. Between now and then, a lot will transpire, including the MMDBL's 6th Annual Rookie & Free Agent Draft. What follows is a summary of off-season activities.

Winter Meetings

From now through January 16, 2025, is the MMDBL's version of the Winter Meetings. No, the owners aren't meeting in Dallas or Nashville to talk trade and sign free agents (wish we were); rather, they are now free to wheel and deal with one another as they shape their franchises' rosters for the January Cutdown Deadline.

When wheelin' n' dealin', GMs should think strategically about their pre-draft roster construction. The MMDBL Roster Management Overview is a great aid. This document notes the following:

  • Teams are required to reduce their rosters to no more than 23 players by the Free Agent Cutdown Deadline (published in the Off-Season Schedule) and this roster may be comprised of up to 20 players as a core plus up to 3 more players who must have “F” durability, or a designation of less than or equal to 100 at-bats versus right-handed pitching (or 30 versus left-handed pitching) or be uncarded in that year’s card set. (Note: Players eligible for +3 Status may also be rostered in the Core-20 Status players.) The “+3” option enables teams to keep players who might have been injured for most of the season and it encourages them to keep prospects, as well.
Shane Baz has finally arrived, paying long-awaited dividends to the Cardinals who retained him in +3 status.

In the Master DB published on the "Resources" tab at www.mmdbl.com, column F titled "+3" includes a value of "1" for all players eligible under +3 roster status for the 2025 season. These players may be retained under +3 status and do not need to be included in your Core-20 status player group. Please note that if you release an uncarded player they go directly into the ZZZNA group and are not eligible for the 2025 draft. If you wish not to lose an uncarded player, then you should retain them as a +3 hold. This past season, Detroit retained 2B Gavin Lux, Texas retained SS O'Neil Cruz, and St. Louis retained P Shane Baz, to name a few examples of +3 retainees.

As teams make trades, they should also be mindful of their strategic end game as keeping only 17 players or 14 players results in compensatory draft picks (Note: This player count calculation includes all players retained, Core-20 and +3). Also, as a result of last season's rule change, acquired draft picks no longer constitute a roster hold, which means a team can trade a player for a pick and reduce their number of retained players.

Bottom line: The "Winter Meetings" are a great time to set your roster construction and draft strategy while evaluating the rookie talent in the ZXFA draft pool to determine the draft's areas of strength and weakness.

Cutdown Deadline

This year's Cutdown Deadline is Thursday, January 16, 2025, at 8 pm CT. Teams should email their cuts directly to [email protected] no earlier than Thursday, January 9, 2025, at 8 pm CT and no later than the Cutdown Deadline.

The reason for the "no earlier than" date is that this is when the Commissioner (GM of the Detroit Tigers) will finalize his cuts and share them with the Associate Commissioner (GM of the Brewers.) Once a team submits their cuts they are no longer eligible to make trades or adjust their roster prior to the first pick of the draft being announced. Once the first pick of the draft is announced, the trading window reopens.

Teams failing to meet roster cutdown requirements by the Cutdown Deadline will have their roster adjusted by the Commissioner to meet the Core-20 and +3 minimum requirements in a manner the Commissioner deems to be in the long-term best interests of the franchise. This will be done immediately so that the Commissioner can quickly turn the final pre-draft version of the Master DB, including the complete free agent pool, by 11 pm CT that same night. As a reminder, only players listed as "ZXFA" in the "MMDBL Team" column are eligible for the draft. Players in the ZZZNA group are not eligible, however, we retain the ZZZNA group in the database as it includes several players who likely will be eligible in future years. You will note that for ZZZNA players who played in the majors in 2024, we include their actual season stats. This provides a glimpse as to which players Dynasty League chose not to card, for one reason or another.

The Rookie & Free Agent Draft

The crown jewel of the offseason is the draft, and the draft format has changed in recent years to be more accommodative to GMs' schedules and preferences. The early drafts were 4-day online Zoom slogs. A few years ago we added Slack as the official notification of picks, and Google docs as the official record of picks. There's a difference -- and this is important:

  • A pick isn't made until it is announced in Slack; and
  • A pick isn't official until it is logged in Google docs

The order of operations is -- 1) announce your pick in Slack (e.g., DET - Shohei Ohtani, P), and 2) copy the player selected from the draft pool tab to the draft grid tab in Google docs, and delete them from the draft pool tab. Once this sequence of events occurs, the draft officiant (Commissioner or Associate Commissioner) will announce in Slack the next team on-the-clock, on-deck and in-the-hole (e.g., STL, TEX, PIT). Once your up, the clock is running on your pick (unless we're in the pre-set time portion of the draft - more on this in a moment.)

The draft this year will have a pre-set time portion and also our traditional Zoom portion in which pick times are not pre-set. We've added the pre-set time portion for two reasons -- 1) reduce the time burden for GMs to be online and at the ready for the entire draft, and 2) provide an opportunity for GMs who'd otherwise miss the whole draft to participate in part of it. When pre-set times are known, a GM is not required to make their pick until the time indicated even if they could make it, in some cases hours earlier, because all teams before them have drafted. This will only apply for Rounds 1, 1s, 2 and 2s, and it may apply to Rounds 18 and after (depending on the number of selections yet to be made, Commissioner to advise later).

Here's the full draft schedule:

  • Rounds 1 and 1s (Slack and Google Docs only) -- Thursday 1/30, begin 10 am CT, pick due every 30 minutes (pre-set times known in advance)
  • Rounds 2 and 2s (Slack and Google Docs only) -- Friday 1/31, begin 10 am CT, pick due every 30 minutes (pre-set times known in advance)
  • Rounds 3 through 9 (Slack and Google Docs only, Zoom-optional) -- Saturday 2/1, begin 5 pm CT, pick due every 2-3 minutes (clock starts when prior pick entered)
  • Rounds 10 through 17 (Slack, Google Docs with Zoom-optional) -- Sunday 2/2, begin Noon CT, pick due every 2 minutes (clock starts when prior pick entered)
  • Rounds 18 to Completion (Slack and Google Docs only) -- Monday 2/3
  • Final Pre-Season Master DB Finalized -- Wednesday 2/5, 10 pm CT
  • Opening Night -- Wednesday, 2/12, 7:15 pm CT (or a rescheduled time to meet you and your opponent's schedules)
What your Slack environment will look like once you arrive.

If you don't have access to Slack, go here to get it on the PC and/or download it on your phone. No subscription is required. You'll want to get to the MMDBL Free Agent Draft group and access the 2025 draft channel (#2025-draft). If you're having trouble, notify the Commissioner. We'll run a test of the Slack draft channel to ensure everyone has access after the Cutdown Deadline. A hack that makes the draft go smoother is using your team's logo as your Slack icon. This reduces all ambiguity as to who is making the selection noted. For example, in the Ohtani example above -- "DET - Shohei Ohtani, P" -- if your team logo is your icon you can simply note, "Shohei Ohtani, P" and everyone will know it is Detroit making the pick. Directions on Google docs access and editing rights will be provided later.

Compensatory Picks

Compensatory picks are a great way to trim unneeded chud from your roster in return for 2 or 3 early round picks. Rebuilding teams have used this strategy to grab young talent and speed up their turnaround. And, of course, the Minnesota Twins did this one year -- cutting to only 14 players -- and went on to win the World Series (only the Twins can do this, you know.) The depth of the draft pool should factor into a GM's calculus, as well as the strength of their roster from Player 15 through 23, and their strategic intentions (rebuild versus reload.)

No team can cut to less than 10 players. Here's how the draft works:

  • Up to 30 rounds, depending on each team’s number of cuts
  • First 2 rounds are worst-to-first (tiebreakers: record, run differential, runs allowed)
  • Remaining rounds are “snake” draft style with first-to-worst beginning in Round3
  • Supplemental rounds after the 1st, 2nd and 5th rounds for teams that retain 10-14
  • Supplemental rounds after the 2nd and 5th rounds for teams that retain 15-17
  • Supplemental rounds are worst-to-first
  • Each team must end the draft with a complete 40-man roster composed of carded and/or uncarded players

What if a GM Can't Attend the Entire Draft?

The extended draft period is a lot, no question. If a GM is unable to meet their draft timetable obligation they can provide a list of players in order of preference to the Commissioner, Associate Commissioner or another GM who will pick on their behalf. A GM should inform the Commissioner who will be picking on their behalf to reduce Draft Day confusion. If a team is getting over-weighted on one position as a result of the draft list approach, we will make adjustments to ensure all positions are adequately covered. However, if you do not want your surrogate drafter to make such adjustments, please indicate as much when supplying your draft list by noting "No Adjustments!"

Teams which have had a surrogate drafter for 5 or more picks will be afforded the opportunity to make post-draft adjustments to their roster involving only players acquired through the surrogate drafter (i.e., they can't cut a player they retained or whom they personally drafted.) These adjustments will need to be finalized by Wednesday, February 5 at 7 pm CT. Players who are cut during this post-draft roster adjustment phase will go into the ZXFA pool and be available for in-season Add/Drop sessions.

Each year the MMDBL makes every effort to schedule the draft when all GMs are able to attend but sometimes this is not possible. As we look ahead to the 2025 offseason, the league is looking into an online draft module it can use to extend the pre-set time portion of the draft with less administration. More to come on these efforts.

Welcome to the offseason. Time to shovel off those snow-covered hopes and build a franchise steeled for long-term success.