Mulling No. 1, the Brewers are on the Clock
Generational talent is a term sparingly used by scouts because they know that making such a declaration is tantamount to saying, “This kid’s gonna be a Hall of Famer when it’s all said and done.”
Since the beginning of the MMDBL in 2020, few players have entered the draft with the “generational talent” label following them. Bobby Witt and Adley Rutschman in 2023 certainly entered with that label. Julio Rodriguez and Gunnar Henderson in 2023 entered with a ton of buzz, too. In 2024, Elly De La Cruz generated a lot of excitement and dreams about what he could become. But no one has entered an MMDBL draft with Bryce Harper or Steven Strasburg-type hype. Until now.

Meet Paul Skenes.
The 6-foot-6, 22-year-old introduced himself to the majors last year and made getting professional hitters out look easy. Skenes blazed through the minors and made his MLB debut in May 2024 as the most anticipated pitching prospect since Strasburg. He didn’t underwhelm. While highly touted prospects such as Baltimore’s Jackson Holliday stumbled in their rookie seasons, Skenes became the Pirates’ ace after only his second start. You might remember that start. It was May 17, 2024, at Wrigley Field, and Skenes left the game on a pitch count after tossing 6 no-hit innings, striking out 11 and walking 1.
Is Skenes the first name off the board in the MMDBL's 6th Annual Rookie & Free Agent Draft later this month?
No one can know for sure. Teams have differing needs. After all, it’s going to be hard to pass on Garrett Crochet, Yobinoshu Yamamoto, Shota Imanaga, Jackson Merrill, and Jackson Chourio. These 5 players, along with Skenes, are likely the first 6 players off the board in the 2025 draft, but even after they're gone there are 4 more players with 3.0 Wins Above Replacement (WAR), making the 2025 draft the richest in terms of current-season impact players.
This year’s draft features a record 766 players – up from last year’s count of 757 – and 66% of all players who appeared in the majors last summer. This year’s draft pool matches the 2024 draft in terms of total value, representing 20% of total WAR, below the 2023 draft record of 24% WAR.
However, this year’s draft matches the notoriously deep 2023 draft pool in terms of impact players, defined as a player with a WAR of 1.5 or greater. This year, there are 33 pitchers and 40 hitters who are impact players. Comparatively, the 2024 draft had 29 pitcher and 29 hitter impact players, and the 2023 draft had 32 pitcher and 41 hitter impact players. Of note, this year’s draft has another 38 pitchers with a WAR of 1.0 to 1.4 – a record.

As is normally the case, the draft is pitcher heavy in terms of value. There are 421 pitchers in the draft pool (55% of the pool) and they collectively represent a record 36% of the pitching WAR totaled in the majors last summer, up from 34% in last year’s draft. There are starter gems in the draft but, as usual, the talent pool is reliever heavy. A record 79% of relief appearances are represented in the draft pool (up from 75% last year), which means only 21% of relief appearances are rostered. This translates to 44% of saves in the draft pool, up from 35% last year but down from a record 51% in the 2023 draft.
Starting pitching is also well represented. 53% of pitcher wins and 60% of losses are in the pool, along with 48% of pitcher starts. This means 52% of pitcher starts are rostered. If you divide the 20 MMDBL teams by the 30 MLB teams, simple math suggests that the top 67% of performers at all positions will be rostered in the MMDBL. So while 48% of starts are available, it’s likely that only 15% of the league’s starts get drafted. Conversely, we can expect 46% of relief appearances to be drafted later this month.

From a position player perspective, the cumulative value in the draft is on the low-end of the spectrum. The 2023 draft set the standard for 12% of position player WAR available – hitter WAR in the draft is typically in the 8-10% range. This year, 8% of position player WAR is available, down a tick from 9% in the 2024 draft. While there are 40 impact hitters in the draft pool, the position player value in the pool gets shallow quickly. Overall, 39% of plate appearances are in the draft, same as in 2023, and 32% of homers and 39% of stolen bases are available.
Teams interested in a youth movement will have choices. Of the 767 players in the draft, 124 (16%) are under the age of 25, compared to 117 and 17% last January. Of these youngsters, 44 offer a WAR of 0.5 or higher, down a tick from the 2024 draft, which had 45, and well below the record 55 in the 2023 pool which is widely regarded as the MMDBL’s best prospect draft ever.
Is there a team primed for a breakout draft? Five teams cut to the level of earning 3 supplemental picks, including a 1st rounder: Kansas City, the Angels, Boston, Seattle, and Cincinnati. In 2024 and 2023, 6 teams cut to this level. Three teams cut deep enough to earn 2 supplemental picks: the Dodgers, Phillies and Twins. In 2024 only 1 team cut to this level, and 2 teams did so in 2023.
Kansas City has 11 Day One picks (1st 5 rounds) – 4 of its own picks, 4 it acquired in trade and 3 supplemental picks. The Royals also have 2 of the top 4 picks in the draft so they are in a position to land 2 of the Big 6. Injury issues are hurting KC’s progress as prized 2024 draftees Evan Carter and Gavin Williams endured brutal seasons last summer, and holdovers Nick Lodolo and Kyle Bradish also suffered significant health setbacks. However, if KC adds 2 of the Big 6 and the health issues disappear, with a cornerstone like Bobby Witt the Royals could be poised to take a big jump.
It may be cold outside but it will soon be time to jump into the pool. With the first pick in the 2025 Annual Rookie & Free Agent Draft, the Milwaukee Brewers select …?