Skip to content

T.W.I.B. › 2021

Toronto Driving for Pole-to-Pole Win in Casey Division

(This is the first installment of divisional previews. Today’s preview features the Bull Durham League’s Casey Division.)

In 2020, the St. Louis Cardinals won the Casey Division in both Season #1 and Season #2 and in the process became the only team in the MMDBL to be in first place in their division all year. This year, the Toronto Blue Jays seem uniquely poised to win the Casey race in Cardinal-esque pole-to-pole fashion.

Devin Williams anchors a devastating Blue Jays bullpen that aims to lockdown a runaway title in the Casey Division

For our preseason analysis, we’re ranking teams according to a single empirical data point – Adjusted Total WAR. First, we total the hitting WAR of each player on a team’s roster, and the pitching WAR of each pitcher. The sum of those two numbers is the Total WAR. We then adjust those figures by removing any player or pitcher who produced a negative-WAR in 2020, under the presumption that they likely will not see the field in the MMDBL in 2021. The resulting number is a team’s Adjusted Total WAR.

In the Casey Division, Toronto has the biggest advantage of any divisional leader in the MMDBL (+9.8 Adjusted Total WAR). In fact, Toronto leads over the 2nd-ranked team (Detroit) in a wider gap than top-to-bottom in 2 of the league’s other divisions! Based on this alone, you couldn’t blame an observer for putting all their money on the Blue Jays, not just to win the division but to take it wire-to-wire.

Toronto Blue Jays

The Jays enter the season with the best Adjusted Total WAR, the best Adjusted Pitch WAR and the second-best Adjusted Hit WAR. Toronto will lean on a stout rotation and absolutely loaded bullpen. Max Fried, Tyler Glasnow, Chris Bassitt, and Pablo Lopez anchor a rotation that will be backstopped by the shutdown trio of Devin Williams, Nick Anderson and James Karinchak. Not mentioned by name are three other relievers with sub-1.00 WHIPs.

The lineup is explosive with 8 players who hit 9 or more homers in the MLB’s 60-game season. If those 8 players hit homers in proportion to their MLB pace last year, Toronto will shatter the MMDBL homerun record. The starting outfield of Mike Trout, Trent Grisham and Alex Verdugo along combine for 6.6 WAR. The starting infield of Luke Voit, Brandon Lowe, Dansby Swanson and Kyle Seager can rake. Catcher Travis d’Arnaud slashed 321/386/533/919 and rounds out one of the league’s most potent offenses.

Detroit Tigers

If Toronto takes the lead on the green flag and doesn’t look back, the battle behind them for the other Casey Division playoff spot figures to be a 4-horse race. Detroit ranks second in the division in Adjusted Total WAR and looks like a much different team than the Tigers who took the field in 2020. Yu Darvish will lead the rotation once again, and will be followed by Spencer Turnbull, Masahiro Tanaka, Adam Wainwright and Danny Duffy.

Prize of the draft Ke'Bryan Hayes will man 3B for Detroit and lead a much-improved Tigers' lineup.

The Tigers return a much better version of Brandon Belt at 1B and add Ke’Bryan Hayes at 3B to secure the corners. Willi Castro is too good to not have a role, but Javier Baez anchors SS. Castro could slot over to 2b and assist Josh Harrison. In the outfield, there’s a strong mix of Robbie Grossman, Aaron Hicks, Jason Heyward, Randal Grichuk and Eddie Rosario.

Chicago Cubs

Last season we chronicled the Cubs turnaround in a TWIB titled The Cubs Turnaround Appears to be Ahead of Schedule. That was midseason, but it appears to be a fair prognostication given that the Cubs can reasonably expect a playoff spot and have accumulated a base of talent that is likely to get better.

It starts with Trevor Bauer in the rotation. Steady Zach Davies and Sandy Alcantara back Bauer, followed by a montage of lefties – Jordan Montgomery, Kris Bubic, Daniel Norris and Nick Margevicius. Edwin Diaz is the undisputed closer leading a collection of arms including Aroldis Chapman, Archie Bradley, Amir Garrett and Riley Smith. Uber-talented rookie Luis Robert and fellow rookie Bobby Dalbec join a lineup that will feature Trea Turner, Matt Chapman, Lourdes Gurriel Jr., Clint Frazier and a rejuvenated Max Stassi.

San Francisco Giants

The eye test would suggest the Giants would rank higher on this list, and when it is all said and done, they may. The team has no boldly discernable weaknesses and seems to be tailored to their cavernous home park. The rotation will be led by Lance Lynn, Zach Plesac, rookie price Sixto Sanchez and Tyler Alexander. San Fran will get good value from Randy Dobnak, scraped from Texas in a trade, and Tanner Houck was another rookie grab who figures to make an impact starting games. The bullpen is solid. Going into the draft, it featured Richard Rodriguez and was bolstered by Mike Mayers and A.J. Minter in the draft.

The off-season pickup of Wil Myers gives the Giants a middle-of-the-order bat to pair with Robinson Cano. Kyle Lewis emerged nicely in his rookie year and will join Starling Marte and Avisail Garcia in the outfield. David Fletcher and Yandy Diaz offer nice production on the inflield, and Garrett Cooper and Colin Moran form a productive platoon at 1B.

St. Louis Cardinals

The Cardinals streak of leading the Casey Division could end on Opening Day. The Cardinals host the Rangers, while the Blue Jays visit the Nationals. But don’t throw dirt on St. Louis yet because, in the words of DJ Khalid, all they do is win, win, win (no matter what). If they begin to lose, lose, lose look no farther than pitching. Going in, the Cards have the MMDBL’s second-worst Adjusted Pitching WAR (Washington). Merrill Kelly, Michael Pineda and J.A. Happ should lead the rotation, though it should be noted that the Cardinals spent the early part of the draft stockpiling arms for the future. Four arms of note – Luis Patino, Spencer Howard, Kyle Wright and Dylan Cease – are stashed for the future.

Like some other teams in the MMDBL, the Cardinals roster features significant talent that under-performed in the COVID-shortened MLB 2020 season. For instance, last year’s superstars Bryan Reynolds and Austin Meadows are not likely to see much playing time. As such, the Cardinals will rely on a lineup of Matt Olson, DJ Lemahieu, Manny Machado, Marcell Ozuna and Paul DeJong. St. Louis also boasts one of the best catching tandems in J.T. Realmuto and Sean Murphy.