Skip to content

T.W.I.B. › 2021

Twins Top Tommy Ranks as Rangers, Braves Close Gap

(This is the third installment of divisional previews. Today’s preview features The Natural League’s Tommy Division.)

Lucas Giolito looks to lead the Twins back to the top of the Tommy Division in 2021, and possibly back to the World Series.

In 2020 Season No. 1, the Minnesota Twins had a season for the ages. The Twins went 43-11 for a record .796 winning percentage, at one point reeling off a record 14 straight wins to pull away with the Tommy Division title. They completed the Dream Season going 12-4 in the playoffs and winning the World Series in seven games over the Oakland A’s. Despite injuries, the Twins managed to make the playoffs in 2020 Season No. 2 before an early exit.

After two seasons of the MMBDL, the Twins are the league’s winningest franchise with a .679 winning percentage, and they enter the 2021 season as the favorites in the Tommy Division based on a 29.3 Adjusted Total WAR, which ranks as the MMDBL’s second-best mark (Toronto, 33.1).

For our preseason analysis, we’re ranking teams according to a single empirical data point – Adjusted Total WAR. First, we total the hitting WAR of each player on a team’s roster, and the pitching WAR of each pitcher. The sum of those two numbers is the Total WAR. We then adjust those figures by removing any player or pitcher who produced a negative-WAR in 2020, under the presumption that they likely will not see the field in 2021. The resulting number is a team’s Adjusted Total WAR.

The Twins are first in the Tommy based on this metric, but it’s close. Texas sits at 26.7 and Atlanta is at 25.9. If the metric is to be believed, the early indication is that the Tommy will largely be a 3-team race as the 2020 Season No. 2 division winner Yankees retool and the Washington Nationals rebuild with the league’s youngest and most prospect-laden roster.

Minnesota Twins

When you think of the Twins’ dominance in 2020 you think of pitching. Minnesota led both seasons with a league-best WHIP (1.07 in Season No. 1, 1.14 in Season No. 2). The core of their success was a rotation tandem of Gerrit Cole and Lucas Giolito and a bullpen anchored by Seth Lugo and Austin Voth. In their memorable Season No. 1, the Twins also raked, finishing second in OPS (Oakland); but they slipped to 12th in OPS in Season No. 2.

This season, the team returns Cole, Giolito and Lugo but it is their hitting that figures to be the strength as the Twins enter the 2021 campaign with the MMDBL’s best Adjusted Total Hit WAR (20.3). Austin Nola and Will Smith form a natural bash brothers behind home plate, with Smith possibly DH’ing versus righties to keep his potent and clutch bat in the lineup. The Eric Hosmer pickup enables Nola to stay behind the dish versus righties as Hosmer provides better defense at 1B. At 2B, Luis Arraez won’t provide any pop but he could bat .400. Donovan Solano also won’t provide much pop, and probably won’t play much in the field, but he, too, could hit .400. Trevor Story will man SS, and Nolan Arenado may be the most-talented 3B in the league, but he had a down year in the MLB. Expect Ty France and maybe Brad Miller to find some time at 3B. In the outfield, Juan Soto is poised to have an MVP-type season and will be supported by Mike Yastremski, Austin Hayes and Byron Buxton. Darin Ruf may get time in the outfield and at 1B.

Cole is still the club’s most-talented pitcher but he may be unusable in certain situations this season. Giolito will be the staff ace and Carlos Carrasco and Mike Clevinger will provide quality starts. The bullpen was largely remade in the draft and looks very strong. Kyle Finnegan, Victor Gonzalez, Caleb Thielbar, Ryan Sherriff, Tanner Scott and Andre Scrubb give the Twins six dependable options.

Texas Rangers

In 2020 there were many times when it seemed the Rangers were ready to take off. They made the playoffs in Season No. 1 but missed in Season No. 2 despite posting the same record (28-26). In both seasons, the Rangers spent time in first place in the Tommy Division but inconsistent run production and starting pitching killed momentum. The team hit lots of homers (85 in each season, the record is 90) and got on base, but posted a batting average of less than .245 in both seasons.

This season, pitching will take center stage. Texas has the MMDBL’s third-best Adjusted Total Pitch WAR (12.9, behind Toronto and Baltimore). Shane Bieber is a Cy Young candidate, and Luis Castillo gives the Rangers a pair of aces. Marco Gonzales is a solid No. 3, with remaining starts coming from Chris Paddack, Jamie Barria, Jose Urquidy and Nathan Eovaldi. The bullpen is solid, especially against lefties. Blake Treinen, Trevor Rosenthal, Drew Pomeranz, Cam Bedrosian and Nick Tropeano form a strong back-end core. Geoff Hartlieb, Craig Stammen and Chaz Roe could also contribute.

Texas surprisingly cut Joey Gallo who, in many ways, personified the hot-and-cold nature of last year’s offensive attack. This year’s attack promises to be more even. Yasmani Grandal will catch, backed by rookie Ryan Jeffers. Another rookie, first-rounder Jared Walsh, will likely see most of the action at 1B, though Tommy LaStella, Rowdy Tellez and even Cody Bellinger could get some action there. A post-draft trade netted starter Cesar Hernandez at 2B, and though he doesn’t provide much pop he’s a much better defender than LaStella. Carlos Correa will hold down SS, and Todd Frazier was added late in the draft to take 3B where he could receive help from LaStella and Jeff McNiel, who figures to get most of his reps in the outfield. Bellinger will play CF and be flanked by McNiel and a combination of Corey Dickerson, Kyle Tucker and Andrew McCutcheon, with Tommy Pham and Jesse Winker also able to fill in.

Atlanta Braves

Dominic Smith posted an explosive slash line in the MLB last season and will lead a Braves offense that figures to be among the league leaders in runs scored this season.

The Braves were in the mix for a playoff spot before fading in the last 2 weeks of Season No. 2. Overall, Atlanta went a cumulative 50-58 over two seasons and, while competitive, couldn’t keep up in a division ruled by the Twins, Yankees and Rangers. The 2021 version of the Braves is much improved and figures to compete to the end with better-than-ever odds of earning a playoff slot.

The Braves are poised to rake in 2021. Atlanta’s Adjusted Total Hit WAR is third best behind only Minnesota and Toronto. Atlanta scored the highest-WAR player in this year’s draft, Salvador Perez, who gives the Braves a decided advantage behind the dish. Not only did Salvie bring his usual great defense, but he hit for average and power while getting on base. Dominic Smith will likely beat out Anthony Rizzo for most of the starts at 1B, though Jedd Gyorko also could contribute versus lefties. Adam Frazier packs a gold glove at 2B but the position will likely need help from Phil Gosselin and Luis Guillorme to contribute offensively. Xander Bogaerts and Brandon Crawford give the Braves a strong duo at SS. Rafael Devers’ poor glove at 3B may force him to DH at times, and the team may look to Guillorme, Chad Pinder and Harold Castro for help at the hot corner. In the outfield, Bryce Harper, Kole Calhoun and Adam Engel will lead the way, as Alex Reyes and Smith will also see time.

Atlanta’s roster is light on starting pitching and heavy on relief, perhaps portending a use of The Opener strategy. One thing is for certain, when Kenta Maeda and Ryan Yarbrough start, they’ll be looking to go deep into games. After that, starts will come from Daniel Castano, Kyle Cody, Tejay Antone and Austin Gomber. The bullpen features a lot of quality innings. Greg Holland, Stefan Crichton, Antony Bass and Rafael Dolis figure to lock down the late innings, with key contributions also likely from Jason Adam, Jordan Weems, Yimi Garcia, Matt Strahm and all of the starters (except Maeda) when they’re not starting or resting from their previous start.

New York Yankees

The Yankees finished 33-21 last season and put up a good fight against the Phillies in The Natural League Championship Series (LCS) before succumbing in 6 games. New York was able to overcome an early season-ending injury to Aaron Judge, making their division title in Season No. 2 even more amazing. This season, the Yankees will have a healthy Judge, but they’ve lost Noah Syndergaard for the season and last year’s staff ace Mike Soroka will be limited. The Yankees had a strong draft from a talent acquisition standpoint but had many holes to fill.

On the mound, the Yankees will turn to free agent signee Johnny Cueto and rookie Dane Dunning as a defacto 1-2 punch. Soroka will be limited but he and Yusei Kikuchi will provide solid starts, and the rest will have to come from Josh Lindblom, rookie Deivi Garcia and Elieser Hernandez. The bullpen has some solid arms in Yency Almonte, Gregory Soto, Phil Maton, Tommy Hunter, Andrew Miller, Taylor Williams and Jacob Webb.

Roberto Perez may now be the best defensive catcher in the game. What he doesn’t bring with the bat will be supplied by Jose Trevino, though Trevino’s defense is suspect. Freddie Freeman is an everyday starter at 1B; and 2B will be shared among Ketel Marte, Jonathan Schoop and Mike Moustakas. Moose could also step in at 3B where Asdrubal Cabrera and Erik Gonzalez figure to see the most time. SS is anchored by defensive whiz Jose Iglesias who this season is a candidate to hit .400 with some pop. In the outfield, Judge is back. He will be joined by rookie first-rounder Ryan Mountcastle, Josh Reddick and Marte. Other contributors in the outfield figure to be Jake Cave and Dee Strange-Gordon, who also can play 2B.

Washington Nationals

Trade acquisition Francisco Lindor understands the Nationals are in a rebuild but he figures it won't be long before it's all smiles in The District.

Under new management this season, the Nationals are boldly trying to change the course of a franchise that has finished with the worst record in each of the MMDBL’s first two seasons, posting a 32-76 clip for just a .296 winning percentage. New leadership hit the trade market, cut 26 players to earn supplemental picks in the first 3 rounds of the March 2021 draft, and drafted young talent with high upside from start to finish. Management made it clear that the focus is not on 2021, but what comes after.

As such, the Nats could be in line for another first overall pick in 2022, though they are expected to be much more competitive even as they watch their young talent come of age. Focusing on how Washington will do in 2021, and who it will roll out onto the field this season, almost seems irrelevant given the focus on the future. Regardless, some familiar names are back. Max Scherzer will be joined by trade acquisition Dylan Bundy atop the rotation. Blake Snell will also chip in, as will Jake Arrieta. Expect the youngsters to contribute, as well, such as Casey Mize, Ryan Castellani, Patrick Sandoval and Adrian Morejon. Stephen Strasburg and Marcus Stroman won’t contribute in 2021 but the Nationals are hoping for full health from the duo who could return in 2022 as front-of-the-rotation-caliber contributors.

Rookie Daulton Varsho can play the outfield though he may see most of his starts behind the dish despite his poor defense there. Michael Perez is more of a defensive catcher but he gets the bat knocked out of his hands at the plate. The club will continue to wait on youngsters Andrew Knizer and Keibert Ruiz to mature and push Varsho to the outfield full-time. In the outfield, offseason acquisition Eloy Jimenez brings a big bat. He will be joined by the returning Brandon Nimmo, free agent signee Joey Gallo, Nick Senzel and Ender Inciarte. Around the diamond, the Nationals will likely go with Rhys Hoskins (1B), Freddy Galvis and Nico Hoerner (2B), trade acquisition and superstar Francisco Lindor (SS), and the trio of Abraham Toro, Carter Kieboom and Isaac Paredes at 3B. First overall draftee Gleyber Torres will likely DH. 2021 may be a challenging season for the Nats but the club is assembling the talent necessary to assure a quick turnaround.