Skip to content

T.W.I.B. › 2021

Whitey Division: Orioles, Phillies and Everybody Else

(This is the fourth installment of divisional previews. Today’s preview features The Natural League’s Whitey Division.)

Corbin Burnes has emerged as an ace and is ready to pace the Orioles rotation.

The Whitey Division last year saw two different division winners (Mets and Phillies) and two different wildcard participants (Milwaukee, now the Orioles; and Houston, now the Dodgers.) The Angels didn’t scratch the post-season but were competitive in both 2020 seasons right down to the wire.

The Whitey may have been the most competitive division in the MMDBL top-to-bottom last year but the pre-season analysis suggests that the competition has stretched into two tiers – a top tier comprised of the Orioles and Phillies, and a second tier comprised of everyone else.

For our preseason analysis, we’re ranking teams according to a single empirical data point – Adjusted Total WAR. First, we total the hitting WAR of each player on a team’s roster, and the pitching WAR of each pitcher. The sum of those two numbers is the Total WAR. We then adjust those figures by removing any player or pitcher who produced a negative-WAR in 2020, under the presumption that they likely will not see the field in 2021. The resulting number is a team’s Adjusted Total WAR.

Baltimore (3rd) and Philadelphia (7th) rank in the top 7 teams in the pre-season ranking according to Adjusted Total WAR, and the Mets, Angels and Dodgers rank in the league’s bottom 6. It’s hard to believe, however, that the Whitey Division will devolve into a two-team race in 2021 as each team has enough pockets of strength to get on a hot streak and let momentum carry them into the post-season.

Baltimore Orioles

At times last year, the Orioles looked like the best team in the league. At the 39-game mark in Season No. 2, Baltimore was a league-best 25-14 with a league-leading +72 run differential. We even blogged about it. Then the wheels fell off. The Orioles went 5-10 the rest of the way to finish in 4th place four games behind the Phillies.

This year, Baltimore is hoping its rotation can lock down games early. The surprising Corbin Burnes, equally surprising Framber Valdez and returning Kyle Hendricks form a very solid rotation core that will be supplemented by Sean Manea, Kyle Freeland, Frankie Montas and Jon Gray. The bullpen has some shutdown characters in the midst, namely Thomas Hatch, Sam Selman, and Alex Reyes. The rest of the bullpen is solid enough – Tyler Rogers, Darren O’Day, James Hoyt, Diego Castillo and Josh Staumont.

The lineup is loaded with pop and will produce a lot of runs. Carson Kelly and Jason Castro will catch with Kelly getting the large majority of the work. At 1B, the team added Joey Votto to go with last season’s HR leader Mitch Moreland, but the Orioles will probably turn to Travis Shaw to take the weakside of the right corner platoon. At 2B, Ozzie Albies scuffled offensively in the COVID-impacted MLB season but is still the best option; and despite an off campaign with the leather, Corey Seager remains the starting SS. At 3B, Yoan Moncada stepped it up defensively but regressed offensively, especially versus lefties, opening the door for a platoon with Maikel Franco. Multi-positional Jurickson Profar will provide steady production and good defense at either corner on the infield or outfield. Post-draft acquisition Willy Adames can’t help defensively but he rakes against lefties. In the outfield, Ronald Acuna will be flanked by rookie Randy Arozarena and a combination of Hunter Renfroe, Brian Goodwin, Scott Kingery and D.J. Stewart. Retiree Ryan Braun will also get his reps.

Philadelphia Phillies

The Phillies perfected The Opener strategy in 2020. The strategy was so effective it inspired a blog and it was also effective enough to carry the Phillies into the 2020 Season No. 2 World Series where they held the mighty Red Sox offense to just 4 homers and a slash of .239/.375/.355/.730. Will Philadelphia use the same strategy in 2021?

In 2020, the Phillies probably needed The Opener to maximize their opportunities to win. In 2021, the club appears to have starting pitching it would prefer to ride with. Dallas Keuchel, Brad Keller, Tony Gonsolin, and Clayton Kershaw give the Phillies a Big Four, all of whom can go deep into games. Only Kershaw could potentially be “matched up” but only by a team filled with reverse lefties – the baseball world’s version of a unicorn. Following the Big Four is a pack of 6 relievers who each have sub-.200 opponent batting averages, sub-.300 OBPs, and sub-.250 slugging percentages. By name, they are Tyler Duffey, Zach Britton, Jarlin Garcia, Jesse Hahn, Cesar Valdez and Brandon Liebrandt. Tyler Clippard, Adam Kolarek and Jesus Tinoco are just cherries on top of a shutdown sundae.

In the field, Gary Sanchez is back as catcher even though he’s returned to his habit of hitting below the Mendoza Line. This opens the door for draft steal Anthony Bemboom who carries a strong arm and crushes righties. Andrew Knapp carries a similar offensive profile. Christian Walker will once again man the right corner, and Brian Anderson and Evan Longoria are back in a platoon at the left corner where the team will have to find a way to get Edwin Rios’ bat in the lineup versus righties. Up the middle, rookie Andres Gimenez is the best defender and future at SS, and draftee Danny Mendick provides solid defense at 2B and is an upgrade over Jose Altuve, who had a down year. SS Jorge Polanco is still around and will see time versus lefties. In the outfield, Kevin Kiermaier is a defensive stalwart in CF, David Peralta will likely man LF and Max Kepler is back in RF. Swiss Army Knife Dylan Moore will need reps wherever he can get them – probably RF or 1B – and Cameron Maybin and A.J. Pollock provide outfield depth.

New York Mets

David Peterson was a rookie draft steal for the Mets.

The Mets won the division in 2020 Season No. 1 and would have made it a clean sweep with a Season No. 2 division title had they been able to beat the Phillies. The Mets went 1-5, including a late-season sweep at the hands of the Phils. Overall, New York finished 3 games behind the division-winning Phillies and the sweep proved to be a dagger in the heart of a promising season.

If the Mets are going to win it in 2021 it will take a strong showing from a solid rotation. Anchored by Jacob DeGrom, the Mets’ rotation also includes Aaron Nola, rookie David Peterson and draftee Kwang-hyun Kim. Peterson and Kim had deceptively good seasons. Other starts will come from Garrett Richards, Martin Perez and maybe Michael Lorenzen, who will also relieve. The relief corps is solid. It begins with shutdown option Liam Hendricks and continues with Tyler Matzek, Evan Marshall and Joey Gerber. Josh Hader can be “worked” by lefties but knows how to work out of a jam. Sergio Romo, Yusmiero Petit, Ryan Thompson and Aaron Loup are also around to eat innings.

Handling the catching duties will be Wilson Ramos and Bryan Holaday. At 1B, Jesus Aguilar brings the most pop and will get help from Matt Beaty. Up the middle, Cavan Biggio will man the keystone with help from Jonathan Villar. Orlando Arcia is the SS of the present, but the club likes rookie Santiago Espinal as its future. Eugenio Suarez once again mashed at 3B despite a low batting average and will compete with Kris Bryant, who can also play 1B and the corner outfield. CF Ramon Laureano had a down year offensively but still brings the range and his calling-card cannon to the outfield, where he will be flanked by Michael Brantley and an assortment of Tim Locastro, Yairo Munoz and possibly Bryant and Beaty. Marwin Gonzalez and Brandon Drury provide infield depth.

Los Angeles Angels

The Angels are looking up at some pretty tough competition in the Whitey Division but no one else has a player as dynamic as Fernando Tatis.

The Angels got off to a quick start in both seasons in 2020 only to fade. The team’s fortunes seemed to go the way of the Big Fly. If the Angels were hitting homers (87 in Season No. 1, 85 in Season No. 2), they were dominating. But then they’d go through periods in which runs were hard to come by and they became the MMDBL’s quintessential 3-true outcome team, ranking among the leaders in homeruns and strikeouts.

To be sure, it was the Angels pitching that was the culprit for failing to scratch the post-season in 2020. This season, however, the Angels can roll out five – count em’ – five solid rotation options. It starts with Hyun-Jin Ryu, followed by Zac Gallen, Lance McCullers, Jose Berrios and Charlie Morton. The bullpen has some top-level performers – Jonathan Hernandez, Oliver Perez and John Gant – before softening a bit. Brandon Kintzler, Eric Yardley, Matt Barnes, Tyler Webb and Carson Fulmer will be relied on to soak up innings and bridge to the back-end of the pen.

Regression in key spots will cost the Angels their signature pop and bash in 2021. The strikeouts will still be there, but C Mitch Garver and 1B Pete Alonso took offensive steps back. Alonso is still good enough to play every day, but Garver will need to be spelled by Luis Torrens, who is a solid offensive performer. Manny Pina provides the strong arm behind the dish to deter late-inning base stealers. Up the middle, the Halos boast sole ownership of all-World SS Fernando Tatis, baseball’s most exciting player. Tatis was unplayable as SS in 2020 but that’s not the case any longer as he’s matched his offensive production with Gold Glove-quality defense. Jean Segura seems best suited for 2B and Josh Donaldson will man the hot corner, though Tommy Edman, draftee Austin Riley and Amed Rosario will need to find a way into the infield mix. At DH, Yordan Alvarez’s injury means a year on the DL, but Giancarlo Stanton is back at full strength and ready to rake. One of the best developments for Los Angeles was the emergence of Ian Happ. Raimel Tapia will join Happ in the outfield, as will a mix of Garrett Hampson, Stephen Piscotty, Bubba Starling and possibly Edman and Riley when they’re not playing the infield.

Los Angeles Dodgers

Adalberto Mondesi still has his speed and great defense but the offensive profile slipped a bit in 2020 and the Dodgers are hoping for a rebound.

After making the playoffs in Season No. 2 and just missing it in Season No. 1, all arrows seemed to be pointing up for the Dodgers franchise. The club moved from Houston to Los Angeles in the offseason in hopes of a new start but many of the players the Dodgers are pinning their hopes on either regressed during the COVID-impacted MLB season or were hurt.

SS Adalberto Mondesi seemed poised to take the world by storm, but a shoulder injury lingered throughout 2020 and severely hurt his offensive output versus righties. OF Nicholas Castellanos looked like he was ready to breakout after moving on from the spacious Comerica National Park, but he also fizzled. 1B Josh Bell broke out in 2019 but fell flat in 2020. Add OF Willie Calhoun and C James McCann to that list. You get the point. When that many key players step back, it’s hard to compensate in the draft. All of the aforementioned players are back in 2021 and will play key roles. 2B Kolten Wong is also back and set to be the team’s most consistent offensive performer. SS Didi Gregorius will take the strongside of the platoon with Mondesi, and draftee Renato Nunez could DH. Other contributors will be OFs Teoscar Hernandez, Adam Haseley and Jake Cave; C Martin Maldonado; and utilitymen Tony Kemp and Rio Ruiz.

On the mound (and with the bat from time to time), Zack Greinke was a stopper for the Dodgers. He struggled a bit in the MLB’s 2020 season but is still the undisputed ace. Zach Eflin and Mike Fiers were also solid contributors in 2020, but they too took a step back in the MLB’s COVID campaign. Rookie Christian Javier, Taijuan Walker, Alex Young and Trevor Cahill will contribute to the rotation mix. The Dodgers return Alex Colome to the back end of the bullpen. Colome led the league in saves last season and will again be LA’s most dependable arm. After that, the bullpen thins into guys who could struggle with the 3-batter minimum, except for Paul Fry, Ryan Borucki and Shane Greene. Other contributors will be Miguel Castro, Jorge Alcala, Ross Detwiler and Yoan Lopez.