Skip to content

T.W.I.B. › 2020

Week 10 - Regression Candidates Abound (Part 2)

I’ll spare the long-winded intro and get straight to the point – here are 10 more players that have performed so far off the statistical mean in the season’s first 30 games that they can reasonably be expected to regress (or progress) to the mean in the remaining 8 weeks.

If you want the long-winded intro, read our last blog. Again, in the spirit of getting to the point, the following 10 regression candidates are not analytically derived. Rather, their respective stat lines meet the eyeball test when compared to their 2019 real-life results, and they are generally full-time players. Only time will tell if they snap back to reality in what’s remaining of 2020 Season #2.

Gleyber Torres has had a frustrating start to the season, but a strong finish could propel the Mets.

New York Mets – No full-timer on the Metropolitans is playing well above their norm, which is amazing considering they’re a respectable 17-13. But two very notable players – Gleyber Torres and Jacob DeGrom – are playing well below their norm. Neither Torres nor DeGrom have been bad, per se, but they’ve not been great, either. DeGrom is 4-1 and tied for the team lead in wins, but his OBA is .279 and his WHIP is 1.37, both much higher than the .206 and 0.97 results of the real-life MLB season. Torres gets my vote for having his plot point farthest from the mean. In the MMDBL’s highly offensive season, Torres is slashing .238/.286/.448/.733 with 6 homers, versus his 2019 results of .278/.337/.535/.872 and 38 homers.

New York Yankees – The Yankees are managing life without Aaron Judge just fine, so you would assume they have a few strong regression candidates. Oddly enough, they really don’t. The Yankees don’t have a single full-time hitter or key pitcher who looks to be egregiously over- or under-performing. Joc Pederson is hitting .301, versus .249 in real life, but his OPS is in line with his 2019 MLB stats. Ketel Marte is hitting .370, but his OPS is also in line with his actual 2019 performance. We have to look past the full-time starters and deep into the cave to find a snap-back candidate. Jake Cave is not a full-timer, with only 71 PAs. However, with Judge out, Cave needs to step up and help fill the void. His slash of .188/.278/.297/.575 is way off his real-life line of .258/.351/.455/.806.

Oakland – The A’s mowed through 2020 Season #1 with a cast of over-performers. It would’ve been hard to find a single key player who didn’t finish with a stat line close to their 2019 results. In Season #2, however, injuries and ineffectiveness have slowed the A’s train. Regression candidates abound. Kevin Newman (.185/.191/.196/.387 versus .308/.353/.446/.799), Brett Gardner (.178/.280/.289/.569 versus .251/.325/.503/.828) and Walker Buehler (.294 OBA, 1.74 WHIP and 6.18 ERA versus .221 OBA, 1.04 WHIP and 3.26 ERA) top the list. As bad as Buehler has been, it’s hard not to select Newman, who's OPS so far in Season #2 is less than half his real-life OPS.

Philadelphia – The Opener makes it tough to identify which Phillies pitchers are performing meaningfully different than in real life. Brad Keller and his .306 OBA and 2.03 WHIP over 11 Opener starts is probably the biggest outlier among pitchers. Given the offensive nature of the MMDBL season so far, perhaps the strongest candidate is Max Kepler. The outfielder is slashing a modest .244/.283/.422/.705 after going .252/.336/.519/.855 with 36 homers in the 2019 MLB season. Giving up 53 points of OBP and 150 points of OPS is a lot to leave on the table in The Natural’s highly competitive Whitey Division.

Paul Goldschmidt hopes to turn it around in the final 8 weeks. The slugging first baseman is hitting .217 with just 3 homers.

Pittsburgh – Paul Goldschmidt didn’t have his typically dominant season in the MLB in 2019, but he was still solid. Goldy hit .260/.346/.476/.822 and still managed to belt 34 homers. The Pirates, however, have seen none of that from their starting first baseman. Goldschmidt has struggled to the tune of .217/.319/.317/.636 and 3 homers. He’s giving up 159 points of slugging and 186 points of OPS against his real-life performance for Pittsburgh this season.

San Francisco – What makes it tough to pick a Giant is that players don’t remain a Giant for very long. If you’re under-performing, you’re likely to be shipped out of town. That’s why we are going with an over-performer. David Fletcher is a really good player. Last year in the MLB, he hit .290 with an OBP of .350. He hit 6 homers and was a 3.4 WAR player. His slugging, however, was a meager .384 for a soft OPS of .734. In Season #2, Fletcher already has 4 homers and is slashing .345/.380/.500/.880. While his average and OBP are in the ballpark of his real-life performance, he’s generating much more pop for the Giants than expected.

St. Louis – Every week we look at the leader board and every week we see Brian Reynolds’ name. Reynolds trails the league leader in homers by what would appear to be too big of a margin to overcome, otherwise he’d be a legitimate Triple Crown threat. Slashing .435/.514/.826/1.340, Reynolds is an astounding 121, 137, 323, and 460 points over his 2019 MLB slashline of .314/.377/.503/.880. He also has 8 homers, versus 16 in real life, and is 7 behind league-leader Mitch Garver. If Reynolds get hot – or hotter – and he starts hitting homers, then maybe the Triple Crown is within reach.

Texas – The Rangers have been one of the better teams in the league since Opening Day. Given this, you would assume their ace Luis Castillo has been his normal self, stacking up quality starts and dominating opponents. In 2019, Castillo yielded a paltry .200 OBA and a 1.14 WHIP as a 4.1 WAR pitcher. Yet with 24 games to go, Castillo has just 2 wins in 7 tries. He’s yielding a .282 OBA and a 1.63 WHIP. While this is not atrocious, it’s clearly the outlier. Texas hitters who are under-performing in terms of batting average – Carlos Correa (.214) and Cody Bellinger (.241) – still have OPSs in the 800s. They’re also hitting dingers: Correa has 9, Bellinger 10.

Toronto – There may be no team with more candidates to progress to the mean. The Blue Jays entire roster is under-performing. On the mound, Chris Bassitt is yielding a .344 OBA and 1.86 WHIP (versus .226 and 1.19), and Max Fried is right there with him, giving up a .349 OBA and 1.96 WHIP (versus .268 and 1.33). In the field, Max Muncy is hitting .214/.327/.436/.763 (versus .251/.374/.515/.889), and Luke Voit is slashing .200/.304/.300/.604 (versus .263/.378/.464/.842). We’re going to give the award to Voit, but not before we highlight the contrast in Muncy’s Season #2 performance versus Season #1 when we went .324/.485/.767/1.252 with 20 homers and led the MMDBL in homers, walks, OBP, SLG, and OPS while finishing 2nd in RBI and 8th in batting average.

Washington – No one on the Nationals is hitting. The team is batting .214 with an OPS of just .613. And while Blake Snell has been abysmal on the mound (.338 OBA and 1.94 WHIP), Jose Peraza has been a desert at the plate. To be sure, Peraza isn’t expected to tear the cover off the ball. He hit only .239 in real life in 2019. But he’s been epically bad through his first 112 PAs for the Nationals this season, batting .084/.140/.093/.234. Yes, his MMDBL OPS is lower than his real-life batting average. That’s really bad, making him a snap-back candidate down the home stretch.