Week 15 - BoSox Stave Off Surging A's, For Now
The Boston Red Sox and Oakland A’s are fast becoming the MMDBL’s first true rivalry. In the first season, the two teams pulled away from the rest of the Sparky Division and collided in the Bull Durham League Championship Series. This season, a return collision in the LCS once again seems a plausible outcome.
The teams renewed their rivalry this past week in a battle for at least a tie for the MMDBL’s best record (with Philadelphia) and it was Boston that prevailed, winning two of three to match the Phillies with a league-best 30-15 record. But this just means the Red Sox have held off the surging A’s – for now, for a day. The A’s are peaking at the right time, and the BoSox are enduring their roughest patch since the first couple weeks of the season. Take away the 2-4 start to the season and the 2-4 run just before the Oakland series, and Boston is 26-7, for an astounding .787 winning percentage. Perhaps regression is expected, if not necessary, making the series win versus the A’s as unlikely as it was unimaginable.

The Red Sox are now 4-5 since acquiring Christian Yelich, Howie Kendrick, Trevor May and Ryne Harper while mortgaging their future. It should be noted that the Chicago White Sox, Boston’s trade partner in the Yeli-Howie deal, are 7-2 since the trade and getting massive contributions from Whit Merrifield (.476/.511/.690/1.202) and Alex Gordon (.385/.529/.385/.914). And it should be noted that Yelich has been a black hole in Boston’s No. 3 spot (.188/.278/.281/.559 with a 33% k rate), even though Kendrick has come as advertised – questionable defense, a high grounded-into double play (GIDP) rate (4 so far), and a dependable rake (421/.463/.447/.911). May has been solid and Harper has been shoddy.
When Boston dealt Kevin Gausman as part of the Yeli-Howie package, it didn’t imagine it would need Gausman this year. However, in Game 2 versus the A’s, Dinelson Lamet was lost for the rest of the season and post-season, so the Red Sox will have to rely on Griffin Canning as a playoff starter. The Lamet injury was not surprising. After all, it was Oakland that blasted him for 18 runs and 6 homers in Game 3 of last season’s LCS. This time, Lamet was cruising – 4 K’s in 1 2/3rd – before the Lamet-vs-Oakland curse got him in another way.
The Red Sox vs A’s series featured its share of drama. In Game 1, Oakland grabbed a 1st inning lead on a solo blast by Michael Conforto (6) and rode a strong start from Walker Buehler (7 1/3rd, 6 H, 2 R, 2 ER, 11 K) to grab a 5-2 win and take the division lead by 1 game. Eric Hosmer continued his intentional homocide of Boston pitching, going 4-4 with a homer (6), as the A’s beat ace Jack Flaherty (8-2). In Game 2, the Sox called on Lamet for the opportunity to avenge his LCS debacle. When he left the game in the 2nd inning, it was 1-1. Cam Bedrosian relieved Lamet and would go 4 innings. Stephen Piscotty roped a 2-run shot (3) off Patrick Corbin in the bottom of the 3rd to give Boston a 3-1 lead.
Bedrosian would blow that lead in the 5th as Marcus Semien blasted a 2-run shot (7) and Nolan Arenado added a solo bomb (9) to give Oakland a 5-3 lead. In the bottom of the 5th, Justin Turner hit a run-scoring double and Ehire Adrianza poked a 2-run, 2-out single to give Boston a 6-5 lead. That lead would hold until Brett Gardner ripped a 2-run triple in the top of the 7th off Harper to give the A’s a 7-6 lead. Oakland turned to remarkably reliable Yusmiero Petit and the league’s top-WHIP bullpen to anchor the win. Boston responded in the bottom of the 8th. Turner tied the game with a single, and Charlie Blackmon belted his 9th homer of the season – a 3-run shot – to give Boston a 10-7 lead and the win.

In Game 3, Oakland found gold with Wilmer Font. The spot start pitched 5 scoreless, 3-hit innings, and Tyler Webb added another 1 2/3rd scoreless. Meanwhile, Rendon hit a 2-run blast (10) off Jose Berrios as Oakland would surge to a 3-0 lead they’d take into the 8th inning. Enter Petit. With 2 outs and bases clear, Yelich hit his 1st extra-base hit and 1st homer (8) as a member of the Red Sox to make it a 3-1 game. Oakland added a run in the top of the 9th to make it 4-1. Turner hit a 2-run homer (9) off Petit to make it 4-3 and Adrianza added a run-scoring triple to tie the game, 4-4. In the bottom of the 10th, Blackmon once again hit the game-defining dinger (10) as Boston eked out a 5-4 win and staved off the surging A’s for now.
This rivalry has roots. In 2020 Season #1, the regular season resulted in a 3-3 split. Oakland won the LCS 4-1, and this season the regular season record favors Boston 4-2, for an all-time Oakland advantage of 9-8. Will these teams meet again in the Bull Durham LCS? Possibly. But St. Louis and the surging Blue Jays and Tigers hope to have something to say about that.
Wherever the road leads, the A’s and Red Sox are pedigreed for battle. Boston leads the league in runs (282) and all four slashline metrics (.286/.365/.493/.858). The A’s are second in runs (264) and all four slashline metrics (.284/.347/.483/.830). The starting rotations are solid but underperforming. The Red Sox 1.41 WHIP is 11th best, and the A’s 1.51 WHIP is 17th, but Buehler is starting to click. When it comes to bullpens, the A’s have a decided advantage with the league’s best bullpen WHIP (1.07), well ahead of Boston’s 15th ranked relief corps (1.42 WHIP).
Heading into the final 9 games fully armed with 40-man rosters, neither team has a distinct weakness-of-opponent advantage. There’s a not-so-remote possibility the two teams could finish best and second-best in terms of overall MMDBL record. But the post-season is merciless and offers no guarantees. A second LCS showdown is possible, however, calling it probable would belie the fact that this is baseball where there is a fine line between diffidence and confidence.