Week 16 – Whitey’s Dilemma; 4 Worthy Teams, 2 Playoff Spots

With a 3-game lead and 6 games to go let’s ensconce the Phillies right now as Whitey Division champions. The real drama lies with who gets the second divisional playoff spot and the right to face the Tommy Division winner, which is looking more and more like it will be the surprising New York Yankees.
Who will win this high-drama thriller?
The actors are the Baltimore Orioles, the Houston Astros and the New York Mets. The Phillies, at 31-17, are in 1stplace by 3 games over the Orioles and Astros, with the Mets 4 games back. The Phillies own the season series sweep (6-0) versus Baltimore, are 5-1 versus the Mets, but just 2-4 versus the Astros. Philadelphia’s remaining opponents are the Nationals (13-35) and Toronto (21-27), which sport a combined .350 winning percentage. Barring a total collapse, the Phillies will close what they opened and take the Whitey Division crown. The big question is whether or not they stave off the Yankees (30-18) and hold onto the No. 1 seed in The Natural League.
That leaves Baltimore (28-20), Houston (28-20) and the Mets (27-21) battling for the Whitey Division Wild Card and the right to play (most likely) the Yankees. Each team has a clear path to the playoffs, but each team also has challenges.
Who’s Hot? Who’s Not?
Houston and the Mets are both 5-5 in their last 10 games, with the Orioles at 4-6. No team appears either too hot or too cold. At closer inspection, though, the Orioles are flagging at the wrong time against the wrong teams. After a 17-3 run that put them in a tie with the Phillies atop the division, the Orioles have gone 2-7, losing 3 games to the Phillies and a pair to the Mets. The Mets appear to be surging, going 5-1 with 2 wins against the Orioles and a sweep of playoff-contender Texas. And Houston has gone 4-2 while coming a single 7th-inning run away from sweeping the Phillies.
EDGE: Mets and Astros
A Schedule Advantage?
Baltimore will play the Angels at home this week before finishing on the road at Houston. The Orioles are 1-2 against both teams but those series were early in the

season before Baltimore’s breakout. The Mets will travel to Houston before finishing at home against the Angels. The plucky Mets took 2 from the Astros the first time the teams met and are 1-2 versus the Angels. The Astros, of course, start with the Mets and finish with the Orioles. No one needs any help – yet. Everyone still controls their own destiny. The Astros, however, have the greater challenge in trying to navigate through both the Orioles and Mets. Both series will be at home where the Astros are 13-8. To quote Herb Brooks, “Great moments are born of great opportunity”, and that’s what the Astros have here “tonight boys.” The Angels have a unique opportunity to play spoiler. Los Angeles was in the thick of the race until a late-season 6-game losing streak knocked them out of contention, but they remain a dangerous offensive force capable of hanging crooked numbers at any time.
EDGE: Orioles and Mets
Will Injuries Play a Role?
The Orioles loss of Ronald Acuna Jr. in Game 2 last week versus the Mets may have contributed to their Game 3 loss in that series, but it probably had more to do with Jacob DeGrom’s gutty performance and Michael Lorenzen’s 3 no-hit innings of relief for the Mets. The Orioles will be without Acuna in Game 1 versus the Angels. While Acuna will be missed, his loss may not be that disabling for Baltimore considering the type of year the superstar outfielder has had. Acuna is slashing just .225/.299/.390/.689 with 8 homers. He has struck out 75 times in 217 plate appearances – a whopping 35% K-rate. Meanwhile, Baltimore will benefit from Fernando Tatis Jr.’s continued absence from the Angels’ lineup. Tatis will miss the entire series before returning to face the Mets. The Angels’ ability to stay in the playoff race was clearly hampered by the Tatis injury. The young shortstop has appeared in only 23 games this season and has slashed .295/.343/.537/.880 with 4 homers. His absence is a boon to the Orioles, and his return is untimely for the Mets. Neither the Mets nor Astros are dealing with any key injuries, so once Acuna returns to the Orioles’ lineup all three contenders will face the final 5 games fully healthy.
EDGE: Orioles (because they play a Tatis-less Angels)
Who’s Armed and Dangerous?
Pitching is down and hitting is up from last season. Nearly every team has its soft spots in the rotation and bullpen, though the Orioles have among the fewest. With the 2nd best WHIP in the league (1.21) behind the reigning champion Twins (1.18), Baltimore has yielded the 2nd fewest runs (173) behind the pitching anomaly known as Philadelphia (163). The Mets aren’t far behind. 4th best in runs allowed (196), the Mets are 5th best in WHIP (1.29). Houston’s WHIP is in the same ballpark (1.32), but when it comes to runs allowed the Astros are 9th best (213). On the surface, the Orioles seem to be the most armed and dangerous of the trio. They also seem to have the rotation advantage, and their bullpen doesn’t lag too much behind the Mets in terms of overall performance.

A lot of it will come down to matchups. In order for the Orioles to get two Justin Verlander starts in the final 6 games, JV will have to go on low endurance for one of them. Stephen Strasburg and Kyle Hendrick should be able to get 2 full-endurance starts in, and Frankie Montas is available for one start. For Houston, ace Zack Greinke should be able to provide a pair of full-endurance starts. However, Mike Fiers will only be able to make one start and Jeff Samardzija could make two starts, though one would need to be on low endurance. Of note, the Astros’ closer and league-leader in saves (16) Alex Colome has only 5 1/3rd innings remaining. From a rotation readiness standpoint, the Mets may be in the roughest position. It was critical that Jacob DeGrom gutted out the Game 3 win against the Orioles, but that effort leaves him only able to start one of the team’s final regular-season games. Aaron Nola will be able to make a pair of full-endurance starts. The club will have a choice to make with Masahiro Tanaka – trot him out there for one full-endurance start or run him out their twice on low fuel. Strategy and matchups will be critical.
EDGE: Orioles
Who’s Locked and Loaded?
The adage that pitching wins championships may hold true in this playoff showdown, but the bats will have a say. Baltimore appears to be the most armed and dangerous, and they may also be the most locked and loaded. The Orioles sport the best slashline and lead the trio in runs scored and homers. Baltimore also leads the trio in stolen bases (49) and is 2nd in the league in that category.

It’s hard to give an edge to the Mets in this category as only two everyday starters are hitting over .290 (Tim Locastro and Michael Brantley) and neither is providing much power (2 homers combined). The next highest batting averages among everyday starters belong to Kris Bryant (.245) and Eugenio Suarez (.236). It is possible that notable under-performers Ramon Laureano (.224) and Gleybar Torres (.212) could join the party, and that would certainly help. A stronger case could be made for the Astros having an offensive edge, even without considering that Greinke is hitting .331 with 4 homers and will likely start two games. Willie Calhoun (.331, 14 homers) is among the league leaders in homers, and Josh Bell is right behind him (.291, 13 homers) while proving to be an OPB machine (.414). Adalberto Mondesi is hitting twice his weight (.286) and providing stellar defense.
The Astros make a strong case, but the stats don’t lie. The Orioles are loaded with game-changing bats. Yoan Moncada (.360, 9 homers) remains among the league leaders in several offensive categories and Corey Seager (.339, 9 homers) is right there with him. The supporting cast of Ozzie Albies (.298), Omar Narvaez (.275), and Mitch Moreland (.274, 13 homers) is solid, even without any meaningful contribution from Acuna.
EDGE: Orioles

Intangibles
This is a hard category to grade but you cannot deny the fact that Mets Manager Reg Welker seems to know a bit about this game. He ranks at or near the top on Dynasty League Baseball’s Tournament Leaderboards and currently holds the highest Career Dynasty Score. Astros Manager Nick Battaglia is also a seasoned vet in Dynasty League Baseball, while Orioles Manager Chris Gunst is in his 1st year. When it comes to winner-take-all scenarios, experience usually matters and becomes an immeasurable X-factor. With 40-man rosters, the final six games promise to be a chess match as managers work to make the right moves without over-coaching their teams into a late-inning box. Will it be Vladimirov's Thunderbolt? The Queen’s Gambit? Or perhaps Bura's Desperado Sacrifice? We’ll know in a few days. Checkmate.
EDGE: Experience