Looking Ahead to the 2024 Rookie Crop

While some teams are bearing down on a playoff spot, others are looking ahead to the 2024 Rookie & Free Agent Draft. This season, the MMDBL has largely split into two distinct factions. The first is composed of 13 teams battling for 12 playoff slots. The other is 7 teams battling for the top pick in next Winter’s draft.
If the season ended today, the draft order for those first 7 teams would be:
1. Boston
2. Cincinnati
3. Kansas City
4. Baltimore
5. Texas
6. Milwaukee
7. NY Yankees
Last year’s draft featured several prized posessions – Julio Rodriguez, Michael Harris, Spencer Strider, Adley Rutschman – to name a few. Those four are potentially generational talents. Does this year’s draft hold the same promise? The early review suggests this draft is weaker, thanks in part to the aggressiveness of several MMDBL GMs to build for the future in last year’s draft and effectively “steal” rookies from the 2024 draft pool. For example, St. Louis took Corbin Carroll and Gunnar Henderson in last January’s draft. Both are having solid MLB rookie campaigns this season.
Another example is Milwaukee, which nabbed Spencer Steer and Esteury Ruiz, and then landed Stone Garrett in a trade. And San Francisco which grabbed Hunter Brown last Winter as Minnesota nabbed Will Brennan. And then there’s the Phillies who took Stuart Fairchild and Freddy Fermin. As a result of being drafted in January, all of these players are ineligible for the 2024 draft unless, of course, they are released.
So who’s left? Below are the Top 30 rookie hitters and the Top 30 rookie pitchers ranked by WAR as posted on Fangraphs as of July 4. The rookies who are currently on MMDBL rosters are slashed out in red. The hitter pool has been picked over -- only 19 of the Top 30 remain. But the pitcher pool remains largely intact except for the pilfering of Brown.


Keep in mind that it's not just rookies who are eligible for the draft, but any veteran who was in the ZZZNA pool, or left undrafted and unclaimed in the ZXFA pool, or uncarded in 2022 but made a comeback in 2023. Some position players who might fit the profile as early round selections next Winter include 1B Brandon Belt, 2B Zach McKinstry, OF Tommy Pham, 1B Mike Moustakas, 1B/OF Jake Bauers, 3B Brett Baty, OF Travis Jankowski, OF Brent Rooker, and OF Mike Tauchman, to name a few. Players like McKinstry, Bauers, Baty, and Rooker can be categorized as post-hype prospects -- players who never clicked in their first several attempts in the majors but are now finding success. Can they sustain it?
Non-rookie pitchers in the draft pool are too many to name, but every year's draft typically features a deep enough reliever pool that a team can entirely reconstruct a competitive bullpen through the draft. Building a rotation through the draft, however, is much tougher unless you take a long view and spend early picks on prospect pitchers who don't provide much current-year value (see the St. Louis Cardinals' rebuild as an example.) Anthony DeSclafani is one notable veteran who is trending toward being a quality early-round starter.
While the players listed below are the Top 30 hitter and pitcher rookies ranked by WAR as of now, there is a lot of baseball to be played and many more rookies to potentially get the call. For example, Carroll and Henderson basically got the call last September and were drafted in the First Round last January. Their usage was very limited for this MMDBL season, but they will be off the leash next year for the Cards. Knocking on the door for 2nd half callups in the majors are a bevy of talented prospects who are at Triple-A and have nothing left to prove -- DET DH Colt Kieth, CLE SP Gavin Williams, BAL OF Colton Cowser, OAK C Tyler Soderstrom, and TBR 1B Kyle Manzardo come to mind. Then there's the guys that have already gotten the call, failed, and are recalibrating in the minors -- BAL SP Grayson Rodriguez, ARZ SP Brandon Pfaadt, and LAD SP Gavin Stone are sterling examples. These are still quality prospects who played enough to likely be carded by Dynasty League in the 2023 season set, but will offer little current-season value.
This summation of talent available in next Winter's draft hardly scratches the surface. And this makes the prediction of top picks a way-too-early attempt to light the fire on offseason scouting and draft preparation. Regardless, providing a list is what we're supposed to do, so here it is:
1. Elly De La Cruz
2. Eury Perez
3. Matt McLain
4. Tanner Bibee
5. Masataka Yoshida
6. Andrew Abbott
7. Kodai Senga
8. Bobby Miller
9. Taj Bradley
10. Bryce Miller
11. Patrick Bailey
12. Bryan Woo
13. Luke Raley
14. Brent Rooker
15. Ezequiel Tovar
16. Logan Allen
17. Grayson Rodriguez
18. Zach Neto
19. Maikel Garcia
20. Anthony Volpe
21. Joey Wiemer
22. Brandon Pfaadt
Enjoy. And watch it all be different in 6 months.