Skip to content

T.W.I.B. › 2023

Playoff Push: Toronto Driven by Unfinished Business

It’s getting late – just 8 weeks of regular-season baseball are left – so now is as good of a time as any to size up the playoff races. Let’s run through the MMDBL’s 2023 competitors by starting with the league’s best team – the Toronto Blue Jays.

Toronto lost the World Series last season but looked like a Championship team all summer and right to the bitter end. A classic comeback in Game 5 gave the Minnesota Twins new hope and left the Blue Jays deflated. Toronto players and coaches were left to absorb the crushing World Series defeat all winter and, to a man, vowed to return stronger, better and more focused. "We got unfinished business to take care of," said Closer Jordan Romano, who's among league leaders with 12 saves. This season, after an uninspiring 14-13 start,

"Unfinished business" is what drives the Blue Jays, according to Jordan Romano, who hopes to finish the business this Fall with a World Series-clinching save.

the Blue Jays have since gone a dominant 29-10 to run their record to an MMDBL-best 43-23. Not only does Toronto have the best record, It owns an MMDBL-best +103 run differential, which is 30 runs better than the next best team (Washington). Toronto is 3rd in OPS (.743, behind the National and Angels), and 2nd in WHIP (1.12, behind Seattle), making them the only team in the MMDBL that is in the Top 6 in the premier hitting and pitching categories.

One other team is in the Top 7 in those categories – the World Champion Minnesota Twins (1.21 WHIP and .725 OPS). Much like the Blue Jays, the Twins struggled out of the gate, stumbling to a 21-28 record. At that time, after a 5-game skid including a sweep at the hands of Cubs, it looked like the Twins hopes to become the MMDBL’s first back-to-back champions were dashed. They’ve since rallied a bit, going 10-7, but still only sit at 31-35, good enough to be the 6th seed in The Natural Division. You get the sense the Twins are better than their record, given the stat lines and the fact that they are +40 in run differential, 4th best in The Natural.

Phillies Phinally Have Company

The Phillies continue to hold the top spot in The Natural, whether by hook or crook. At 39-27, they are tied with the Nationals and have a solid a +53 run differential and are on a 6-game winning streak. The “hook or crook” has to be the Phillies bullpen, which sports a 5th-best 1.20 WHIP and an amazing 31-11 record, indicating once again that Philadelphia is maximizing 'The Opener' magic that almost propelled the club to a World Series title in 2020 season No. 2. Phillies relievers have tallied 326 innings pitched, or 45 innings more than the next closest team, while only yielding a .207 opponent batting average. Hitting just .236 as a team (16th best in the MMDBL), the Phillies are fire when it matters. They are batting a league-best .305 with runners in scoring position (RISP) and two outs, and a 2nd-best .266 in RISP situations. Philadelphia also leads the league is steals (84) as well as times caught stealing (26).

The Nationals are 39-27 – tied with the Phillies – and hold the best run differential in The Natural (+89). They are first in OPS (.778) and hold a whopping 32-basis point lead over the next best team (Angels). The Nats hold the league lead in homers with 84, paced by Eloy Jimenez (13), Jazz Chisolm (11) and Keston Huira (11). Yes, Keston Huira. In terms of pitching, the Nats have the 9th best WHIP (1.24), but the bullpen has been stellar. Washington relievers have the league’s 3rd best WHIP and OBA of 1.15 and .201, respectively. Washington is also hot, having won 12 of its last 14 and 8 in a row. The Nationals were once a good rebuilding story; now they are a fully loaded pennant contender.

We’ve already mentioned the Angels without actually talking about the Angels. But the Angels should be talked about. At 34-29, Los Angeles is 3.5 games behind Philly and Washington in The Natural. And with a +45 run differential, they are 3rd best in The Natural behind Philly and Washington. The Angels have been one of The Natural’s top 3 teams all year and are led by a stellar offense, 2nd in the MMDBL in OPS (.746) and 2nd in OBP (.331). Pitching-wise, the Angels are middling with the MMDBL’s 12-best WHIP (1.27), and their bullpen has been suspect (17th best WHIP of 1.35, and a 7-10 record with 9 blown saves). But LA can straight up mash, led by potent offensive stars Yordan Alvarez, Pete Alonso and Xander Bogaerts.

In the Natural, the 4th and 5th ranked teams currently are a bit of an enigma. The 4th ranked Dodgers (35-31) are 4 games behind Philly and Washington but hold a -33 run differential, which is 8th worst in the MMDBL. But the Dodgers are one of only two teams in The Natural (Angels are the other) that have a winning record against the juggernaut Bull Durham Division. The Dodgers and Angels are 32-28 against The Bull Durham (.533 winning percentage), and the rest of The Natural is an embarrassing 94-146 (.392 winning percentage). Despite their status in the playoff race, the Dodgers have been both buyers (acquiring Alex Manoah) and sellers (peddling Justin Verlander and others). The buy-side impulse is likely driven by a pitching rotation that ranks among the league’s best (starters have the 2nd lowest WHIP, 1.12, but are only 19-23); and the sell-side reaction is likely the result of a paltry offensive attack which holds the MMDBL’s 3rd worst slash line (.229/.288/.357/.645).

Atlanta's Aaron Judge is running away with the MMDBL's homer title with 26.

Atlanta is The Natural’s 5th-ranked team (31-31, 6.5 games back) and has a -6 run differential. The Braves are one of the top-scoring teams in the league and trail only the Nats with 81 homers (Aaron Judge has 26 with a remarkable .333/.432/.718/1.151 slash). Their rotation, however, has been brutal. Starters are yielding a 4th-worst .273 OBA and 1.45 WHIP, and a 5th-worst 5.07 ERA, but if the club can lean on Judge, Freddie Freeman and Michael Harris, they could make a run.

It's Been a Bull (Durham) Market

Toggling back to The Bull Durham, the Blue Jays (43-23) own a 1-game lead over the White Sox and Tigers. The Tigers (42-24) have The MMDBL’s 3rd-best run differential (+72), and the ChiSox have the MMDBL’s 9th-best (+41). But the White Sox have been a different team of late. Chicago was hot out of the gate, surging to 18-6 before a 7-14 swoon felled them to 25-20. Injuries played a big part in that losing patch. Since, the White Sox have gone an astounding 17-4, including a 9-game winning streak and their current 5-game streak. The offense is led by Mookie Betts (.256/.369/.487/.857 and 14 homers), and Zack Wheeler and Aaron Nola compose a formidable 1-2 rotation punch.

It's thumbs up in Detroit when spiritual leader and centerfielder George Springer is healthy, but thumbs down when he's not.

Detroit’s season has followed a similar path, starting a league-best 18-5 before a spate of injuries hit. The club then slogged through a 6-11 trough before piecing together its current 18-8 stretch. The club’s injuries have been an epidemic. This week, Shane McClanahan and Logan Webb each revisited the injury bug for the third time. Griffin Jax also caught the bug. Fellow relievers Ryan Pressly and Ryan Tepera have spent time on the DL, as have SPs Brandon Woodruff and Jon Gray; and the club lost SS Willy Adames for a 21-game stretch, 2B Luis Urias for 14 games, 3B Alex Bregman for 18 games and CF George Springer for 16 games. In fact, during the 6-11 slog, the Tigers scored 2 runs or fewer 9 times and really missed Springer. Upon Springer’s return, Detroit won 13 of 14 with key contributions from their centerfielder along the way. Since that 13-1 run, however, the Tigers are currently 5-7 and nursing more injuries. Tigers’ pitchers have the lowest ERA in the league, the lowest OBA (.218) and the 3rd-lowest WHIP (1.15), while yielding the fewest homers (38). Detroit is the only team to not yet allow opponents to score 200 runs. But hitting has been uneven. The team is middle-of-the-pack in runs, bottom quartile in hitting with RISP and RISP with 2 outs, and 2nd worst against lefties, slashing a meager .244/.322/.352/.674.

Seattle (39-24) and the Cubs (40-26) are both computer-managed renegades but trail the Blue Jays by just 2.5 and 3 games, respectively. Seattle is pitching-dominant and leads the MMDBL in most major pitching categories. However, Jacob DeGrom is overworked and shut down for the year. The Mariners have hit only 21 homers all year (dead last by a long shot) but have scored more runs than the Tigers. Key to Seattle’s success is an on-base oriented attack that has it ranked 3rd in the MMDBL in batting average (.263) and 4th in OBP (.330).

The Cubs are also hitterish, 2nd in the MMDBL with a .268 batting average, and 4th in runs (310) and 3rd in OPS (.743, tied with Toronto). Cubs starters have pitched really well, ranking 6th with a 1.19 WHIP and 4th with a .237 OBA. Notably, neither the Mariners nor Cubs have had any injuries since going on the Computer Manager. Since then, the Cubs have gone 31-14 and the Mariners have gone 9-6 – a combined 40-20 record and .667 winning percentage. Hmm, right?

Hit Machine Luis Arraez is leading the MMDBL with a .353 batting average and pacing a surging Giants offense.

Which brings us to San Francisco. The Giants are 39-27 and 4 games behind Toronto with a convincing +59 run differential (4th best in the MMDBL). The Giants became a different team after acquiring Ty France. The club started 10-15 before going on a 24-6 tear that included a league-best 13-game winning streak. Since the France acquisition, the club is 29-12. The Giants are 1st in the MMDBL in batting average (.271) and OBP (.334) and trail only Washington in runs scored (346 to 348), despite hitting only 43 homers. The team is 2nd in steals (71) and manufactures a lot of runs. The Giants also lead the league in RISP slash line (.299/.359/.450/.809). 2B Luis Arraez is batting an MMDBL-leading .353.

The Cardinals are only slightly on the outside looking in. At 37-26, the Cards are 4.5 games back and 0.5 games behind the Giants, who currently hold the 6th seed. St. Louis was once 13 games over .500 but are currently on a 4-7 slide. Not a big slide, but big enough to lose ground against every team above then in The Bull Durham except for Detroit. The Cardinals have gotten big contributions from their prized rookies, Corbin Carroll and Gunnar Henderson, slashing a combined .320/.395./.598/.993. But Carroll and Henderson are down to their final at-bats and the Cardinals will have to turn to others for late-inning contributions. Overall, the Cardinals have a bottom-third offense but a healthy +34 run differential. Like the rival Tigers and Mariners, they are driven by pitching. The Cardinals’ staff has the MMDBL’s 4th-best WHIP (1.19) and 5th-best OBA (.226) while keeping the ball in the park (2nd to in fewest homers allowed, 41).

So which two teams in each league will get byes to the Divisional Series? In The Natural, the Phillies and Nationals are looking like the odds-on favorites. In The Bull Durham, it looks like Toronto and -- drumroll -- we'll go with the Giants. Or the ChiSox. OK, so we basically picked the hottest teams in each Division, but with just 24 games to go, it will likely come down to a question of who's hot and who's not. Anything could happen, however. Injuries, ineffectiveness, and just sheer good or bad luck.

(Next T.W.I.B., we'll tackle how the 2024 Rookie & Free Agent Draft is stacking up and who are the top prospects that could go early.)