The Draft Pool's Not as Deep as '23; It's No Wading Pond Either
A year ago at this time MMDBL teams were looking forward to diving into a draft pool that was astoundingly deep. Perhaps it was the residual impact of COVID slowing player development in 2020 and 2021 that led to a stacked draft; or perhaps it was just time for many top prospects to emerge all at once.

Theories abound, but who really knows.
Unquestionably, last year's draft winner was St. Louis. The Cardinals ridiculously nabbed OF Corbin Carroll, 3B Gunnar Henderson and 1B Spencer Torkelson all within the first 18 picks. In doing so, the Cardinals mildly declared that they weren't "all-in" on 2023 and were more interested in building a foundation to compete for the next decade. They may have just accomplished that. Carroll, Henderson and Torkelson all produced stellar seasons, with Carroll and Henderson winning the NL and AL rookie of the year awards, respectively, and Torkelson launching 31 bombs.
How deep was the 2023 draft? Deep enough to sink a well and mine for prospects. In all, 32 pitchers and 41 hitters had a WAR of 1.5 or greater. As we look forward to the MMDBL's 5th Annual Rookie & Free Agent Draft (beginning Feb. 1, 6 pm CT, click here for details), 29 pitchers and 29 hitters have a WAR of 1.5 or greater (see lists below). Last year, the draft pool accounted for 67% of players to participate in the Majors, representing 24% of the total Wins Above Replacement (WAR) for the 2022 season. This year, 757 players accounting for 66% of those who appeared in the MLB are in the draft, representing 20% of WAR.
The draft pool is pitching heavy, as it has been in all prior drafts. 34% of pitching WAR is in the draft, versus 9% of position player WAR. A whopping 75% of relief appearances are in the draft. Last year, 51% of saves were available; that number is down to 35% in the 2024 draft pool. 51% of pitcher wins are also in the draft pool. From a position player perspective, 39% of plate appearances (PAs) are in the draft along with 30% of homers.
Is there a team primed to remake its future this draft as the Cardinals did in 2023? Possibly. Kansas City owns a record 10 Day One picks (Day One includes 5 rounds plus supplemental compensatory picks). Six of those picks are in the top 49 as Kansas City owns 2 1st rounders, 2 2nd rounders, a supplemental 1st, and a supplemental 2nd. Boston and Cincinnati also are primed to make a run, each owning 8 Day One picks. Boston owns the top pick in the draft, followed by KC and then Cincinnati.
So who will Boston take first overall? Among pitchers, Kodai Senga (3.4 WAR, 1.22 WHIP) looks like a prime candidate, though he is 30. Tanner Bibee (3.0 WAR, 1.18 WHIP) and Bobby Miller (2.8 WAR, 1.10 WHIP) are younger considerations, both age 24. Cole Ragans (2.2 WAR, 1.16 WHIP) is only 25 and had a breakout season. Yennier Cano (1.7 WAR, 1.00 WHIP) looks like an uber-reliever. Grayson Rodriguez (1.8 WAR, 1.34 WHIP) was the near-consensus top pitching prospect when the season began, and he settled in after taking a beating and surviving an early demotion.
Among hitters, OF James Outman (4.4 WAR, .248/.353/.437/.790) is the top-WAR player in the draft and a post-hype prospect who broke out in 2023. 2B/SS Matt McLain (3.2 WAR, .290/.357/.507/.864) can flat out rake and he bashed his way through 3 levels and into the majors last season. 2B Zach Gelof (2.9 WAR, .267/.337/.504/.840) is the only good story in Oakland, or Vegas, of wherever they'll be playing this season. 2B Edouard Julien (2.8 WAR, .263/.381/.459/.839) is a classic all-bat no-glove infielder who hits righties and gets on base. C Patrick Bailey (2.8 WAR, .233/.285/.359/.644) is a defensive whiz behind the dish who makes his pitching staff better. Royce Lewis (2.4 WAR, .309/.372/.548/.921) was a one-time can't-miss prospect who finally broke free from injuries in 2023 and made his mark in the majors. And let's not forget about SS Elly De La Cruz (1.7 WAR .237/.300/.410/.710) who can fill every category on the stat sheet, including strikeouts, and flash leather on the left side of the infield.
Of the 757 players in the draft, 127 (17%) are under the age of 25, and 45 of those youngsters have WARs of 0.5 or higher (see list below). This year's draft has some intriguing young players in it, substantial pitching depth and several position players who can solidify a platoon and fortify a team's bench. If it's light on anything, it doesn't have that obvious breakout star who one could reasonably see as a franchise cornerstone for years to come. Then again, we may never see another draft pool like we did in 2023 when Julio Rodriguez, Spencer Strider, Michael Harris, Adley Rutchman, Bobby Witt, Riley Greene, Corbin Carroll, and Gunnar Henderson all were available.


