Skip to content

T.W.I.B. › 2020

Week 16 – Yankees Will Win the Division After All

Prepare the champagne. Take the MTA to the Upper West Side and join the pinstripe party at Dive Bar. The New York Yankees will win The Natural’s Tommy Division.

Let those words hang in the air and float around a bit. Perhaps they are only a thought bubble that’s about to burst and the reigning world champion Minnesota Twins or potent Texas Rangers will really be crowned division champs. Just give it a few more weeks and one of those teams will surely catch the Yankees, right?

Going, going gone for the season is Aaron Judge. But that hasn't derailed the Yankees.

Nope. Not this season. When they officially clinch the division title, the Yankees will have defied long odds to emerge as Division champions and they will have done it in a most peculiar way – overcoming injuries, being dominant on the road, doing the right things at the right time and preventing runs with an unheralded pitching staff.

The Yankees began the season as steep underdogs. The team was coming off a 19-35 first season – the 3rd worst record in the league – and was undergoing a change in leadership. New manager Alan Schultz used the draft to compile a roster of complimentary role players, including relievers who could win key matchups and hitters who could own one side of a platoon and contribute in other ways (running, defense, etc.) He also made a key preseason trade to shore up the infield defense, dealing Adam Wainwright for Jose Iglesias.

Other than that, there were no big and bold pre-season changes to the core of a team that mustered only 19 wins last season after losing star outfielder Aaron Judge to injury early in the inaugural campaign. It seemed the biggest hope was for Judge to remain healthy so the Yankees could hang with the Twins, Rangers and Braves – all teams they finished behind last season. That hope was gone in Game 21. Judge was lost for the season while diving for a ball in rightfield. His season would end with a powerful slash of .320/.426/.660/1.086 and 4 homers in 50 at-bats. At the time, the Yankees were 13-8, 2 games behind the 15-6 Rangers and 1 game ahead of the 12-9 Twins. Most observers figured that was it; that the Yankees would slowly fade to black and the spotlight would shift to the Rangers and Twins.

The Yankees were just getting started.

Now, at 30-18, with a 4-game lead and only 6 games to go, The Yankees will win the Tommy Division after all. Battling for the division’s wildcard playoff spot are Texas and Minnesota, both 26-22 and preparing for a 3-game series this week in Minnesota that could settle it. Meanwhile, the Yankees will face Atlanta with a chance pop the champagne at home, before finishing at Texas as the Twins finish at Atlanta.

On the season, in head-to-head competition, the Yankees are 2-4 versus the Twins and 1-2 versus the Rangers. However, they own a hallmark series sweep against the Phillies (31-17), they’re one of only two teams (St. Louis) able to boast about series wins against Boston (33-15) and Oakland (32-16), and 2 weeks ago they took 2-of-3 from Minnesota to exact a modicum of revenge for a merciless June sweep.

With a +51 run differential, the Yankees are 5th best in the MMDBL, 3rd best in The Natural and tops in their division by a wide margin (Texas +36, Minnesota +29). In terms of run prevention (198), the Yankees are 4th best in the MMDBL and trail the Gerrit Cole-Lucas Giolito led Twins by only 4 runs. When it comes to scoring runs, the Yankees are 7th in the MMDBL, 3rd in The Natural and trail the potent Rangers by 9 runs in the Tommy Division (258 to 249).

The Yankees don’t do anything great, but they do everything well. Despite playing home games in a renowned hitters park that has in the past yielded homers at a record pace, the Judge-less Yankees are 10th in home runs. And even though they are 5th in batting average (.264), they are a middle-of-the-pack 8th in OPS (.783). However, when it comes to getting hits when it matters, the Yankees have the league’s 3rd best OPS with runners in scoring position (RISP) at .831 (Oakland, .879) and the 2nd most homers in RISP situations with 19 (Baltimore, 21). If they do anything great, it’s hit when it matters.

Freddie Freeman leads a timely Yankees attack,

The offense is led by Ketel Marte (.335/.399/.553/.953 with 9 homers), Joc Pederson (.290/.363/.551/.914 with 10 homers), Mike Moustakas (.264/.359/.544/.903 with 14 homers), and Freddie Freeman (.286/.380/.508/.888 with 10 homers). Few teams can match having four players who are that productive. Even platooner Nick Markakis is having a stellar season, slashing .315/.412/.523/.935 with 6 homers while walking (18) more than he’s whiffing (17). The club has struggled to replace Judge’s production. Trade acquisitions Chad Pinder and Jonathan Schoop have failed to produce, and free agent signee Melky Cabrera has rarely been used. The biggest beneficiary in terms of playing time as a result of the Judge injury has been Jake Cave, but he continues to hit below the Mendoza line.

Yankee bats have been timely; Yankee pitching has been consistent. Yankees pitchers have combined for a 1.27 WHIP – 4th best in the league (Minnesota, 1.18) – and they are 1 of only 5 teams with an ERA under 4.00. A key to their run prevention has been avoiding the long ball. Despite playing in the Yankee Stadium bandbox, the club has yielded the fewest homers (48) in the MMDBL. Opponents are also batting only .237 against them – again, good enough for 4th best (Minnesota, .223). Much like its hitters, the team’s pitchers are best when it matters most. Opponents have a league-low 6 homers with runners in scoring position against the Yankees, and an OPS that is 149 points lower than Yankee hitters in RISP situations (.682 vs .831). Over half of the Yankees’ +51 run differential has been earned with RISP.

When opponents scout the Yankees’ rotation, they notice Noah Syndergaard. Thor is big and a household name. However, due largely to injuries, his image is bigger than his game much like a Frilled Lizard who puffs his neck wide to appear more ominous than he really is. True to form, Thor gives the Yankees’ a brand name, but he is the club’s least effective starter (4-2, 1.45 WHIP, 4.74 ERA). The rotation standouts feature a mish-mash of veteran journeymen and young guys vying to emerge as top-tier starters. Homer Bailey (6-1, 1.44 WHIP, 3.93 ERA) is the journeyman, and he and Thor are flanked by a more youthful trio of Mike Soroka (3-6, 1.13 WHIP, 3.69 ERA), Robbie Ray (4-1, 1.26 WHIP, 3.13 ERA) and Anthony DeSclafani (2-0, 0.93 WHIP, 1.29 ERA).

DeSclafani was added in a trade deadline deal that significantly bolstered the rotation’s depth. The bullpen also received an injection of depth via trades as the Yankees added Felipe Vazquez, Jacob Webb, Austin Adams, Will Harris, and Luis Perdomo. Vazquez and Perdomo have been immensely effective since joining the team. Harris and Adams have struggled. Collectively, the bullpen has given up fewer homers and fewer runs than any other bullpen while oppressing opponents to a .224 opponent batting average (OBA).

Getting homers and scoring runs at the right time and preventing homers and runs at the right time are a big reason the Yankees, at 18-6, have the league’s best road record. It’s a big reason they have won their first division title and earned their first playoff birth, and it will be a big reason they earn the Natural’s No. 1 seed if they are able to catch the Phillies.