Skip to content

T.W.I.B. › 2024

Smackdown: The Natural Again Proving Its Dominance

As anticipated, the Natural League is better than the Bull Durham League and it’s not even close. The “senior circuit” and “junior circuit” narrative is alive and well.

Sonny Gray and the Nationals' enjoyed their dominance of Bull Durham foes in the MMDBL's first 5 weeks and are licking their chops for more inter-league play.

Just 15 games into the 2024 MMDBL season and the Natural teams have dominated. Through 5 weeks (147 head-to-head games) the Natural is 84-63 for a .571 winning percentage. Before the season, the MMDBL’s Advanced Analytics Department (MAAD) predicted the Natural would outperform the Bull Durham League, projecting that 7 teams in the Natural would finish above .500, versus just 3 in the Bull Durham.

So far through 15 games, the Bull Durham League has 1 team – count ‘em – just 1 that has a record of better than .500. Congratulations to Seattle for weathering the inter-league gauntlet and emerging with a 9-6 record and 2-game lead in the Bull Durham. Meanwhile, in the Natural, 8 teams are above .500 through 15 games. Washington leads the Natural (and the MMDBL) with a 10-5 mark but is being chased by 7 teams with 9 or 8 wins, so it’s a tight bunch out of the gate.

Is this historic inter-league dominance we're witnessing? No. The Natural dominated Bull Durham teams in the MMDBL’s first 4 seasons, posting a winning percentage of .551 in head-to-head games. Their most dominant season was 2020 No. 2 in which the Natural posted a .587 winning percentage, but far fewer inter-league games were played then. Last season, Bull Durham posted a .580 winning percentage versus the Natural – the only season in MMDBL history that Bull Durham was the better league. So far, 2024 is looking like “business as usual” with the Natural back in the driver’s seat.

The end of Week 5 marks the completion of the first 1/6th of the season, and Week 6 brings the first stretch of intra-league games. Below are some takeaways from the season’s first 15-game stretch.

The Bats Are Back

The 2023 season marked MMDBL lows in many offensive categories – a trend we chronicled as last season unfolded. On a per-team/per-game basis, runs (4.24), doubles (1.78), triples (0.19), homers (0.90), walks (2.97) and hits-plus-walks (11.54) all hit record lows. So far, it’s early, but offensive output is up in 2024 in every category; and triples and steals are on a record pace. In fact, steals are up 82% over 2023’s record pace – perhaps not surprising given the larger bases and new runner hold rules.

Offense appears to be back in vogue as 2024 is trending in the middle of MMDBL offensive seasons. So far, per-team/per-game runs are at 4.74, a full half-run better than 2023’s record low and slightly less than a half-run behind 2021’s record of 5.16. Despite the Angels’ outburst, however, homeruns are still low by historical standards, as are overall hits and doubles.

Speaking of the Angels

Yordan Alvarez is averaging a homerun virtually every other day and the Angels are bashing 2.13 homers per game, far ahead of the record 1.69 homers per game the Twins hit in 2021 when they launched 91 dingers in 54 games. The Angels are on pace to finish with 192 homers in 90 games. For comparison, in 2023, the MMDBL’s only other 90-game season, Atlanta led the league with 125 homers.

Yordan has 7 bombs to pace the Angels on a record homerun pace through 15 games.

The Angels’ current pace is astounding. Alvarez leads the league with 7 homers in 54 at-bats and is on pace to hit a record 42. Teammates Mickey Moniak and Marcell Ozuna are right behind with 6 bombs each. Aaron Judge holds the 90-game season record, clubbing 39 last year for the Braves. What makes the Angels’ pace even more astonishing is that Austin Riley has yet to click. The slugging third basemen has just 1 homer and is slashing .140/.210/.193/.403 (AVE/OBP/SLG/OPS).

The homer barrage has the Angels on top of the league with a .496 slugging percentage (SLG). The homerun power was on full display this past week as the Angels belted 8 homers in a 3-game sweep of the Tigers. Ozuna hit 2 homers each in games 1 and 3.

National Treasure

After starting 1-3, the Nationals have gone 9-2 to claim the league’s best record after 5 weeks (10-5). The team is currently on a 4-game winning streak and sitting near the top in most pitching and hitting categories.

The club leads the league in on-base plus slugging (OPS) with a slashline of .275/.340/.490/.830 and is 2nd in the league with 5.60 runs per game (Philadelphia, 6.13). The slugging mark trails only the bashful Angels – a testament to Washington’s league-best 4.46 extra-base hits per game. The offense is balanced, too. The Nats have the 2nd best OPS versus lefties and 3rd best versus righties.

On the mound, only Minnesota has a lower WHIP and ERA. Washington has posted a 3.05 ERA with a 1.14 WHIP while yielding a league-lowest .180 opponent batting average (OBA). The starters and relievers are both contributing. Starters have a 2nd best ERA (2.91) and 3rd best WHIP (1.15); meanwhile relievers have a 3rd best WHIP (1.13) with no blown saves. If there’s a unit not yet pulling its weight it would be the defense. The Nationals have the 2nd most errors (15) and have yielded the most steals through 15 games by a wide margin (39 to 31, Baltimore).

Add it all up and Washington is a league-best +29 in run differential through 15 games.

Skipping .400; Shooting for .500?

The MMDBL has never had a .400 hitter, but why settle for .400 when you can shoot for .500? It’s early and there’s a long way to go, but the Giants’ Luis Arraez is hitting .500 through 1/6th of the season, batting a cool 32-for-64. Arraez flirted with .400 for the early part of last season before hitting a summer swoon and finishing with an MMDBL-leading .344. In 2022, Arraez finished 5th with a .315 average (Michael Brantley, PIT, .351).

The MMDBL’s single-season record belongs to Juan Soto who batted .393 for the Twins in the 2021 season. With 32 hits in the bank already, Arraez is padding his account for late-season withdrawals. Let’s set the record straight – he won’t hit .500 but his super-fast start and prolific hitting prowess make the 2024 version of Arraez the MMDBL’s best bet yet to achieve the .400 mark.

Bizarre Love Triangle

The Detroit Tigers are off to a rocky start and a big reason is a string of bizarre occurrences. “Every time I see you falling I get down on my knees and pray” are lyrics sung by New Order in the 1986 song Bizarre Love Triangle which so far is also the soundtrack for the Tigers’ 2024 campaign.

Falling they are. It started on Opening Day when Logan Webb exited in the 5th inning and was declared out for 3 days. Then Yu Darvish went down for 16 days minutes into his first start of the season. Then Jonah Heim was lost for a game. A day later, Webb plunked the Nationals’ Jazz Chisolm and was ejected and suspended for 8 games. (Chisolm got the worst of it and was out for 15 games.)

The Webb suspension hamstrung the Tigers because he had to remain on the major-league roster and couldn’t be replaced. Things couldn’t possibly get any worse, right? Wrong. In the team's home opener against the Dodgers, the situation grew significantly more dire when the Tigers lost their best pitcher and hitter for 15 days on the same play. Shohei Ohtani was forced to leave his 2nd start of the season in the 4th inning and also had to be replaced as DH in the cleanup spot.

Other injuries have also slowed the Tigers’ roll – Alex Bregman for a game and Willy Adames and Shintaro Fujinami each for 3 games. Another big blow was dealt in the last game of the Tigers’ sweep last week at the hands of the Angels when Brendan Donovan was injured stealing 2nd and declared out for 21 days.

Brendan Donovan was safe at 2nd but out for a month as the Tigers lick their wounds in an injury-laden start to the season.

The injuries have forced the Tigers to give critical innings and at-bats to players who were Plan B (or Plan C) when the season began, as well as free agents brought in to plug holes. Hunter Brown was called up to make a start, Andre Jackson was signed when Ohtani went down and has made a start, and Fujinami has made a start and pitched more innings than the club ever intended before he succumbed to injury. After losing Adames and Donovan, the club claimed Jose Fermin and has actively been working the phones looking for a trade partner willing to deal middle infield help.

If you take away all the bizarre occurrences, however, you’re still left with a Tigers’ team that is significantly underperforming. In 15 games, Webb is the only starter to earn a win. Starters have given up a league-high 16 homers in 15 games and have the 4th worst ERA (5.75).

The team’s hitting is even worse. The Tigers are dead last in overall batting average (.210) and are hitting a paltry .196 versus righties, worst in the MMDBL. The batting averages up and down the order are abysmal – Adames .091, Masataka Yoshida .154, Mark Canha .154, Ryan Jeffers .154, Christian Yellich .196, Justin Turner .196. The poor hitting spans all situations, as well. The Tigers are hitting .204 with runners in scoring position (RISP) and .196 with RISP and 2 outs.

The Bluest Skies You’ve Ever Seen

While the Tigers languish and the Natural beats up on the Bull Durham League, one “junior circuit” team stands tall. The Seattle Mariners are the only Bull Durham team with a winning record versus the Natural (9-6). They also are 1 of only 2 teams in the Bull Durham with a positive run differential (+7, ahead of Detroit’s +3). After 15 games, the Mariners stand alone atop the Bull Durham with a 2-game lead.

Seattle’s bullpen is the team’s strength. Among bullpens, it has the MMDBL’s 3rd lowest OBA (.193), 2nd lowest WHIP (1.12) and 2nd lowest ERA (2.75). Moreover, the bullpen is 5-0 and has saved a league-leading 6 games while blowing none. This is all good news for the Mariners because they may be emerging as the Bull Durham version of the Phillies – a team that gets more innings from relievers than it does starters.

Who is Robert Garcia, you ask? He's one of the reasons the Mariners' bullpen is near the top as he's 3rd in ERA (1.08) and 4th in strikeouts per 9 (12.42) among qualifying pitchers.

Everyone knows the exploits of the reigning World Champion Phillies. The Phillies have mastered the art of The Opener. In 2023, their starters averaged less than 4 innings per outing and they were the only MMDBL team whose relievers tossed more innings than their starters (55.7% versus 44.3%). This season, the Phillies are at it again, leading the league with 82 relief innings for an astounding bullpen utilization rate of 60.2%. Seattle, however, is right behind with 78 2/3rds innings of relief for a bullpen utilization rate of 57.8%. Through 15 games, Seattle and Philadelphia are the only 2 teams with bullpen utilization exceeding 50%.

With the Phillies, high bullpen utilization is the game plan. Is this true for the Mariners, as well? Given the performance of Mariners’ starters, the frequent use of relievers might be an act of self-defense. Seattle starters are last in the MMDBL in WHIP (1.74) and ERA (6.91). Opponents are batting .301 versus Mariners’ starters and have crushed a league-most 16 homers in just 57 1/3rd innings – a homer every 4th inning.

It might be intentional but not for the same reasons as the Phillies. The Mariners are rationing Jacob DeGrom’s few remaining innings, and he has pitched well in his 2 starts (.128 OBA, 0.53 WHIP, 0.79 ERA). Outside of Christian Javier, Julio Urias and Joey Luccchesi, the rest of the rotation features young guys cutting their teeth – Grayson Rodriguez, Logan Allen, and Reese Olson. The Mariners didn’t snag Rodriguez, Allen and Olson to be openers over the long term. Rodriguez, in particular, has immense talent and could emerge as a true MLB ace as soon as this summer.

While the bullpen covers the flaws of the team’s starters, the hitters are doing just enough to win games. The club is 9th in OPS and 6th in AVE and OBP. It is averaging a 6th best 5.27 runs per game even though it is hitting a 2nd worst 0.67 homers per game (just 10 homers so far.) Leading the charge is Yandy Diaz who is slashing .444/.557/.611/1.168 and has walked more times than he’s struck out (15 to 12). Diaz is 2nd in batting average behind the incomparable Arraez, 1st in OBP, 7th in SLG and 4th in OPS.