The Race for the Bull Durham Byes Just Got Very Interesting
The Texas Rangers and Detroit Tigers spent the last two months convincing everyone that the Bull Durham’s two playoff byes were settled. Entering play this past week, the Rangers had a 1-game lead on Detroit, and the Tigers were 7 games ahead of Seattle. The Mariners were the first of 6 contenders bunched within 5 games of one another.
The Mariners looked

like a solid playoff lock but hopes of catching one of the Bull Durham’s two frontrunners and snagging a coveted Wildcard Round bye seemed remote. However, the acquisitive Mariners this week pulled off one of the MMDBL’s biggest blockbuster trades ever, involving 14 players and picks, and have dramatically changed their odds of not only making the playoffs but of potentially earning a bye.
The race for the Bull Durham’s byes is now officially a 3-horse race, with still more time before the trade deadline for things to be shaken up further.
Detailing the 14-Piece Trade
Here’s the trade:
- The Mariners receive 2B/OF Mookie Betts, 1B Garrett Cooper, C Miguel Amaya, P Michael Wacha, P Mike Clevinger, P Jay Jackson, and P Ryan Borucki
- The White Sox receive SS Anthony Volpe, P Grayson Rodriguez, P Nestor Cortes, P Ryan Weathers, P Brandon Williamson, and Seattle’s 1st and 2nd round picks in the 2025 Rookie & Free Agent Draft
Seattle became a markedly better team in so many ways, which we’ll step through in a moment. But it didn’t come cheaply. The

Mariners gave up two young cornerstones in Volpe and Rodriguez and two early picks that could become Volpes and Rodriguezes. Volpe is a slick-fielding shortstop with 20-homer pop and an on-base profile. He’ll likely never hit for high average, however, he has shown an ability to crush left-handed pitching, and so far in his young career he holds his own enough against righties to profile as a top-of-the order hitter.
Rodriguez has had his ups and downs in the majors, but when you toss aside his early 2023 season struggles, his stat line is top-quartile for pitchers with at least 20 starts since the 2023 MLB All-Star Break, posting a 1.19 WHIP with a .236 OBA and showing reverse-righty tendencies. Setting stats aside, Rodriguez profiles as a future staff ace. Adding the southpaw Cortes to the haul could give Chicago a Big Three for 2025 if prized trade chip Zack Wheeler survives the deal deadline with the Pale Hose. Cortes is off to a strong 2024 start, posting a 1.10 WHIP in the MLB.
What the Mariners Get in the Deal
It begins with Mookie Betts. Arguably one of baseball’s 5 best players (Ohtani, Judge, Gunnar, Witt, Soto in the mix), Mookie has added being a positional Swiss Army Knife to his resume the past two seasons – a resume already featuring Gold Gloves and Silver Sluggers and an MVP trophy. It seems like Mookie has been around forever but he is only 31 and showing no signs of slowing. Certainly, his major-league injury factored into Chicago’s decision to make him available, and finding a replacement of Volpe’s level to step in at short next year made the parting of ways palatable.

This season, Betts steps right in as Seattle’s best hitter. The MMDBL Advanced Analytics Department (MAAD) maintains a proprietary player score, called the “Total Hit Score”, which is based on current-season offensive card outcomes. For the 2024 MMDBL season, MAAD has Betts as having the 5th best Total Hit Score, behind only Aaron Judge, Shohei Ohtani, Corey Seager and Yordan Alvarez. In the formula, on-base and extra-base hits matter, as do homers, power and clutch hitting. Singles that advance runners two bases are more valuable than station-to-station singles. Low double play and strikeout percentages also improve outcomes (in that they reduce “bad” or unproductive outs).
Putting a bat like Betts in the heart of the order changes everything for Seattle. Against righties, the Mariners with have a formidable order featuring Betts, Yandy Diaz, Max Muncy, Charlie Blackmon, and Luke Raley, all of which are varying shades of green on the green-white-red scale of offensive output as measured by the Total Hit Score. Versus southpaws, Betts, Diaz, Teoscar Hernandez, and Jon Berti are now joined by the clutch-hitting Cooper, giving the Mariners’ lineup greater length and pop. Despite being use-limited, Amaya adds depth in the catching ranks, as well as a prospect to build with for 2025 and beyond.
The Mariners’ offense was struggling before the trade, ranking 15th, 16th or 17th in the most important categories (AVE, OBP, SLG, OPS, homers). Against righties, they rank in the 13th to 15th range for the critical offensive categories. The best player has been Diaz, who is slashing .353/.462/.537/.999 with 6 homers, 19 doubles, 34 RBIs and belongs in the MVP conversation.
In Betts and Cooper, the Mariners are adding 15 homers and 49 RBIs. This is a huge add when you consider Seattle has only hit 44 homers and driven in 252 runs. If you’re doing the math, the incoming dinger total equates to 34% of Seattle’s total dinger count for the season. Betts accounts for 11 of those homers and is having a near-MVP season, slashing .280/.371/.512/.883. He was far and away the White Sox best offensive performer.
A Revamped Stable of Arms
The trade begins with Betts but Seattle likely would not have pulled the trigger if it didn’t come with a starting pitching makeover, which is really what the team needed to chase a Wildcard Round bye.

Let’s talk stats. Seattle is 29-28 in spite of its starting rotation. Mariners’ starters are 11-21 with 5.87 ERA and 1.55 WHIP. The ERA and WHIP are 2nd-worst in the MMDBL. The bullpen has picked up the slack, posting a 3rd-best 1.18 WHIP and 4th-best .212 OBA. Seattle relievers have tossed 250 innings this season, versus 254 for its starters, and only Philadelphia has tossed more bullpen innings. This dynamic should change, thanks to the Betts trade. Joining Mookie on the plane to Seattle were 4 pitchers, including 2 who are expected to step right into the rotation, Wacha and Clevinger.
Wacha struggled with the White Sox but should pitch better in Seattle. He has clearly underperformed, posting a 1.65 WHIP. Clevinger has performed solidly – a 1.36 WHIP – which will be a huge upgrade if he does that in Seattle. Pitching in Seattle alone, a notorious pitchers’ park, will help Wacha and Clevinger post better results. Wacha and Clevinger will join a rotation expected to involve Cristian Javier, Reese Olson, Logan Allen and a couple more Jacob DeGrom starts. Javier has been a breath of fresh air to Seattle, posting a 1.18 WHIP, .202 OBA and 2 complete games in 10 starts.
The bullpen also got better in the trade. Borucki and Jackson are upgrades though they are use-limited. Regardless, they will provide Seattle a formidable bullpen for the playoffs.
So Will Seattle Snag a Bye?
It’s possible. The math is improved – much improved. The odds are better. In our season preview blog on February 9, MAAD listed Seattle as having a 45 Expected Wins (ExW) total heading into the season. You can read that blog for all the asterisks and caveats (such as it’s a real-life usage-weighted formula that doesn’t take into account how an MMDBL manager will manage the team, plus more.) The ExW of 45 predicted a 4th place finish for the Mariners in the Bull Durham behind Detroit (56 ExW), Texas (54) and the White Sox (48).
Clearly, the White Sox have tapped out and are now projecting (and hoping) to draft 1st overall in next Winter’s draft. And they won’t come close to their pre-season 48 ExW and a lot of it has to do with under-performance, injuries and earlier season trades that resulted in the exodus of Aaron Nola, Jake Cronenworth, David Robertson, and Gabriel Arias. The White Sox have a new post-blockbuster ExW of 36. (Note: Revised ExWs don’t take into consideration how the team has done to date; it simply recalculates how a team would be expected to do if the evaluated roster was the same for an entire 90-game season.)
Seattle’s ExW has jumped up to 53, now 3rd best in the Bull Durham (Detroit and Texas are now both 55). Where has the jump come from? Seattle’s Total Hit Score (higher is better) has jumped from 191 in the pre-season to 203 following the trade; and its Total Pitch Score (lower is better) has moved from 138 to 127. Before the season, Seattle had the 13th-best Total Hit Score and 10th-best Total Pitch Score. It is now tied for the 5th-best Total Hit Score and tied for the 6th-best Total Pitch Score.
If the season started over, the race for the Bull Durham byes would look like a threesome among Detroit, Texas and Seattle. But the Mariners find themselves with 33 games to go and trailing by 7 games. Can they catch the Rangers or Tigers? Injuries could play a part down the stretch and, of course, luck could play a part. One thing’s for certain – it’s a brand new season in Seattle and anything can happen in the playoffs, which is likely where you'll find the Mariners this Fall.